Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Proposal: Admin Edits, Darth Edition

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 18 Mar 2009 08:12:21 UTC

Make a new rule, “Admin Cuts”:

Once per Act an Admin, called the Editor, may cut one scene from the Act before it is fiinished.

Redoing the other proposal.

Comments

Influenza:

03-17-2009 16:28:14 UTC

imperial But who decides which admin is the editor? and will the editor be a different admin?

Influenza:

03-17-2009 16:29:31 UTC

uhh I mean will the editor change between acts :d sorry for the double comment ^^

Kevan:

03-17-2009 16:30:10 UTC

I guess the first admin to grab the scissors gets it.

against Seems a bit unfair on non-admins. Giving a specific player the job of “Editor” might be interesting, though.

Klisz:

03-17-2009 16:30:35 UTC

The Editor is whoever goes and decides to do it first… when a rule says “a player, called X, can do this”, then X is whoever does that first.

Klisz:

03-17-2009 16:31:08 UTC

Posted at the same time as Influenza and Kevan.

Klisz:

03-17-2009 16:32:38 UTC

imperial  author def; I’m only doing this to help Gill Smoke anyway.

Rodlen:

03-17-2009 17:04:47 UTC

against Hell no.

ais523:

03-17-2009 18:56:29 UTC

against Cutting a scene should do something, I think.

Kevan:

03-17-2009 19:13:29 UTC

It does; the scene’s writer loses points, and the scene doesn’t make it to the wiki archive.

Devenger:

03-17-2009 19:18:50 UTC

against I’m against admins having unnecessary advantages. As said above, giving the title to a willing and active player through a proposed rule would be good.

Jeid:

03-17-2009 19:37:17 UTC

imperial

Qwazukee:

03-17-2009 19:38:40 UTC

against Although there’s nothing wrong with the editor idea.

Darknight:

03-17-2009 20:06:40 UTC

against

gill_smoke:

03-17-2009 22:32:06 UTC

for It’s my Idea, I’m not an admin but I’d like the thought of Editor(s) trying to keep the ‘film’ on track.

Klisz:

03-17-2009 22:59:08 UTC

Gill, your vote does nothing. I voted def, Devenger voted against, therefore this is self-killed.