Thursday, October 30, 2008

Proposal: And while we’re on the subject

reached a quorum, final vote 8-0—Yoda

Adminned at 31 Oct 2008 22:36:57 UTC

Add the following text to the end of the Rule entitled “Victory and Ascension”:

A Declaration of Victory may not also be any other type of Official Post unless the rules concerning that type of Official Post explicitly state otherwise.

posted by Bucky at 30 Oct 2008 03:08:00 UTC Comments (11)

Comments

Clucky:

10-30-2008 03:16:31 UTC

Didn’t you try and win this way a few years ago?

for

Rodlen:

10-30-2008 03:20:20 UTC

for

Yoda:

10-30-2008 03:51:55 UTC

for 8-|  Do tell.

arthexis:

10-30-2008 04:00:25 UTC

Perhaps we should Generalize this into the Glossary:

Any single Official Post cannot be of two different types of Official Post unless a rule explicitly states otherwise.

Purplebeard:

10-30-2008 14:08:54 UTC

imperial

Kevan:

10-30-2008 15:03:28 UTC

for Good point from Arthexis.

Rodney:

10-30-2008 19:17:55 UTC

against This would give a sene of legitimacy to /other/ Offical Post shenanigans. I want to see a generalized version or none at all.

Tripwire:

10-30-2008 20:11:20 UTC

against I like Arthexis’s way better.

Clucky:

10-30-2008 21:08:44 UTC

Yoda—Bucky made a post that was a CfJ, but also had the DoV flag. CfJ passed and Bucky tried to claim because the DoV passed as well that he won.

Dustin:

10-30-2008 21:50:37 UTC

for

Aemos:

10-31-2008 03:45:40 UTC

for