Tuesday, November 04, 2008

Proposal: Because it’s dishonorable

reached quorum, final vote 9-0—Yoda

Adminned at 05 Nov 2008 12:49:00 UTC

Add a new Tradition to the list in Rule 2.10 as follows:

The Revered Ancestor Scrubfist has stipulated that no Clansman may bring Armor to a Duel to First-Blood.

In the Rule entitled “List of Valid Items”, change the text

If a Clansman having the Wicker Shield in his inventory

to

If a Clansman is holding a Wicker Shield

Comments

arthexis:

11-04-2008 05:21:05 UTC

for Fair enough

Yoda:

11-04-2008 05:33:30 UTC

for

SingularByte:

11-04-2008 08:08:13 UTC

for

Kevan:

11-04-2008 10:31:25 UTC

against The concept of “holding” is ambiguous, and I don’t think you can not hold a Shield that you own; “The Items held by each Clansman shall be tracked in the GNDT.”

We need to distinguish items owned from items brought along to a duel, rather than using “holding” for both.

Rodney:

11-04-2008 11:39:25 UTC

for With Singular’s fix.

Purplebeard:

11-04-2008 20:34:34 UTC

imperial

Kevan:

11-04-2008 21:33:00 UTC

for  for CoV with the fix.

Dustin:

11-05-2008 17:20:09 UTC

for

Clucky:

11-05-2008 20:32:10 UTC

for