Sunday, August 23, 2009

Call for Judgment: Can we end the chaos?

Fails 1-9. - Qwazukee

Adminned at 23 Aug 2009 14:46:18 UTC

End BlogNomic. Start a new nomic, titled “BlogNomic”, with one initial rule:

If all players unanimously agree, a change to the rules or gamestate can be made.

This is legal because I think it needs urgent attention.

Comments

Klisz:

08-23-2009 18:47:50 UTC

for

Wakukee:

08-23-2009 18:51:14 UTC

...the heck? Why??

Klisz:

08-23-2009 18:52:28 UTC

Wak: Mua ha ha. This is part of an evil plot to conquer Albania. ##nomic has talked about it.

Wakukee:

08-23-2009 18:53:27 UTC

...no, really. I need an explanation.

Wakukee:

08-23-2009 18:54:03 UTC

Also, I don’t think this has any effect on the gamestate…

Qwazukee:

08-23-2009 18:55:12 UTC

against It does have an effect on the Gamestate: that of ending it. But our Ruleset is really tight and has been honed over generations, I see no reason to get rid of it.

Klisz:

08-23-2009 18:56:04 UTC

Wak:

1. It is part of a plot to conquer Albania! Sheesh.

2. It has an effect on the gamestate - namely, repealing all rules and adding one rule.

Klisz:

08-23-2009 18:56:29 UTC

Posted at the same time as Qwaz.

Wakukee:

08-23-2009 18:57:19 UTC

DC—Really, why do you want to end bognomic? Albania oesn’t even make sense.

Klisz:

08-23-2009 18:58:01 UTC

Wak: Read the title of the CfJ.

Wakukee:

08-23-2009 18:59:46 UTC

So why end the Nomic? Why not the dynasty? Simple.

arthexis:

08-23-2009 19:01:21 UTC

against

Klisz:

08-23-2009 19:01:32 UTC

Dynasties and CfJs cause chaos. It stands to reason that removing dynasties and CfJs will reduce chaos. Q.E.D.

Rodlen:

08-23-2009 19:14:47 UTC

against

Wakukee:

08-23-2009 19:15:57 UTC

against

Ienpw III:

08-23-2009 19:25:34 UTC

against No real reason given.

Rodlen:

08-23-2009 19:46:14 UTC

This feels like one of those old spam CFJs from ages ago.

Qwazukee:

08-23-2009 19:48:24 UTC

Yeah, good times.

Bucky:

08-23-2009 19:54:33 UTC

against

Ienpw III:

08-23-2009 19:58:56 UTC

This is flawed, anyway. If we start a new nomic, by default it will have no players.

Darknight:

08-23-2009 21:02:06 UTC

against since it’ll cause even the core rules to poof.

ais523:

08-23-2009 21:44:03 UTC

against Too many loopholes in this. If you want to replace the entire ruleset, replace it with one that’s been proven to work in practice.

Pavitra:

08-23-2009 21:44:56 UTC

against This will increase, not decrease, chaos.