Any Clansman who is not already a Combatant or a Prepared Combatant in a Duel, apart from the Referee who announced it, may step forward to fight in that Duel by posting a comment to it, stating such an intention, and listing the Items they are taking to the fight.
Since I am already a combatant, but I am the referee of this duel at the same time, I may join it.
No, being a combatant or a prepared combatant and being a referee are two different conditions. Just because you are both does not mean that you can join.
"Nomic is a game in which changing the rules is a move. In that respect it differs from almost every other game. The primary activity of Nomic is proposing changes in the rules, debating the wisdom of changing them in that way, voting on the changes, deciding what can and cannot be done afterwards, and doing it. Even this core of the game, of course, can be changed."
Comments
arthexis:
I do! I hold no items :D
arthexis:
Per rule “Duels”:
Any Clansman who is not already a Combatant or a Prepared Combatant in a Duel, apart from the Referee who announced it, may step forward to fight in that Duel by posting a comment to it, stating such an intention, and listing the Items they are taking to the fight.
Since I am already a combatant, but I am the referee of this duel at the same time, I may join it.
Rodney:
This is made of pure deviousness.
Yoda:
No, being a combatant or a prepared combatant and being a referee are two different conditions. Just because you are both does not mean that you can join.
Purplebeard:
I agree with Yoda. I don’t think you can join this.
I’ll join. I hold no items.
Purplebeard:
I’ve sent in my moves. Anyone who wants me to win can join this duel and not send in any combat moves.
Purplebeard:
I just remembered that I probably won’t have internet access this weekend, so I could never stop Yoda from winning before I do. I withdraw.
Purplebeard:
I’ll join again. I hold no items. This time I won’t send in combat moves.
Confused yet?
arthexis:
@Yoda: Yeah, in truth following the spirit of the rule, I am not able to join. But if you read the rule literally…
Clucky:
I’ll join.
If I understand the ruleset correctly, by not sending in a list Purplebeard wins in 24 hours.
arthexis:
Purplebeard or Clucky can still win if they make a quick Declaration of Victory to stall the game.