Proposal: Fix to part three fix
Timed out 9 (!) votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan.
Adminned at 10 Feb 2010 10:36:54 UTC
In Rule 2.5 Bloodline replace “If two Guests should ever have the same degree, the Executor should choose one of those Guests at random and raise or lower their degree by 1.” with
If two Guests should ever have the same degree, the Executor should choose one of those Guests at random and raise their degree by 0.5.
If a new Guest arrives, he could mess up the order… See fix part three for details.
Comments
Keba:
With this new Proposal I also changed “1” to “0.5”, because this minimize the mess-up effect even more.
Darknight:
Put:
I still don’t get why kevan vetoed fix part three, my proposal didn’t remove the possibility of a non heir guest becoming heir through the arrival of a new guest
Keba:
Kevan was right.
My Proposal said we shoud remove “or lower” in the last sentence of the Rule. Your Proposal added a new sentence, so Kevan was not able to remove “or lower” in the last sentence.
Kevan:
It would have timed out and had no effect about an hour later; I thought I might as well veto it and give Keba the slot back, since I was an admin who was awake.
Put:
Ah, that’s why you should quote sentences when you refer to them >_>
Darth Cliche:
There:
Put:
spikebrennan:
Purplebeard:
Nausved: