Monday, January 28, 2013

Proposal: Forgot about the implicit vote

Reaches quorum 9-2 and is enacted. -scshunt

Adminned at 29 Jan 2013 14:14:50 UTC

Amend the rule “The Party Line” by replacing “loses 3 Credibility” with “loses 2 Credibility”.

Allow some face-saving for those who self-kill, and avoid penalizing those who don’t more harshly than was intended.

Comments

Patrick:

28-01-2013 01:16:17 UTC

for  arrow

RaichuKFM: she/her

28-01-2013 01:24:30 UTC

for  arrow

Larrytheturtle:

28-01-2013 02:39:43 UTC

for  arrow

Cpt_Koen:

28-01-2013 02:54:11 UTC

imperial  arrow

Kevan: he/him

28-01-2013 08:50:32 UTC

for

Josh: Observer he/they

28-01-2013 08:53:40 UTC

against

Josh: Observer he/they

28-01-2013 08:55:35 UTC

3 Credibility isn’t a huge penalty, and changing it to 2 doesn’t seem like a worthwhile stimulus.

Purplebeard:

28-01-2013 09:25:14 UTC

imperial

RaichuKFM: she/her

28-01-2013 11:29:30 UTC

They’ll still lose 3 unless they self-kill, in which they lose 2.

Josh: Observer he/they

28-01-2013 11:37:08 UTC

Oh, yeah, the implicit. CoV for

Skju:

28-01-2013 12:48:55 UTC

for  arrow

nqeron:

28-01-2013 15:27:53 UTC

for

Klisz:

28-01-2013 18:23:16 UTC

for

quirck: he/him

28-01-2013 18:47:46 UTC

for

Clucky: he/him

28-01-2013 19:41:20 UTC

against I like that this makes you have to write better proposals. We should penalize the self-killers, not just make it weaker for everyone.

Murphy:

28-01-2013 23:25:49 UTC

against

Skju:

29-01-2013 12:58:39 UTC

Why isn’t this passed?

Spitemaster:

29-01-2013 16:20:04 UTC

for  arrow

scshunt:

29-01-2013 17:16:09 UTC

Skju: Because my vote doesn’t count.

Patrick:

29-01-2013 17:40:12 UTC

@Skju I believe this rule explains it.

Votes, other than VETO, cast by the Speaker on a Proposal are not Valid unless every other Honourable Member has voted on that Proposal or that Proposal has been pending for more than 48 hours.