Monday, August 15, 2011

Fweep: Disregarding the food chain

Closed by Josh. Overturned 3-1.

Adminned at 17 Aug 2011 01:04:39 UTC

Josh claimed a Frag for Blacky’s death by StickyBomb. Rule 2.7 prevents this.

Comments

Josh: Observer he/they

15-08-2011 07:56:19 UTC

against It prevents me from claiming a frag for his death. I didn’t; I claimed a frag for dropping a stickybomb on him. His death merely triggered the effect.

Kevan: he/him

15-08-2011 08:26:33 UTC

against

scshunt:

15-08-2011 10:21:46 UTC

His death caused you to gain a frag.

I don’t see why this is any different from, say, grabbing a stickybomb and then killing yourself. You can’t gain a frag from your own death.

scshunt:

15-08-2011 10:22:07 UTC

(err, purportedly caused you to gain a frag. I maintain you actually didn’t gain one)

Josh: Observer he/they

15-08-2011 10:40:03 UTC

I don’t see why this is any different from, say, grabbing a stickybomb and then killing yourself

It’s not, really, and that should be fixed, but the syntax in the ruleset is what it is, and it’s clear that I get the frag for fobbing the bomb, not for the death itself.

Ely:

15-08-2011 21:12:23 UTC

against