Friday, November 21, 2008

Declaration of Victory: I like my new job

less than a quorum of votes, final vote 1-8—Yoda
hiatus ends

Adminned at 21 Nov 2008 12:04:38 UTC

Per Rule 2.5 “Occupations” I have set my Occupation to Narrator.
From now on I am a Narrator, and therefore I have achieved victory.

The rule doesn’t say I have to pick the occupation from the occupations document, only that I may change it to any occupation.

Comments

arthexis:

11-21-2008 08:03:24 UTC

for Explicit author FOR. I am sure some of you won’t like me trying for a DoV so soon, but you will have to argue against my logic first.

ovangle:

11-21-2008 08:54:09 UTC

There is no such occupation. A narrator is a dramatic device, not a job. You can be employed as an orator, an author, an actor or a journalist, all of whom narrate events and stories, but you cannot be employed as a narrator. against

ovangle:

11-21-2008 09:07:14 UTC

Withdrawn, for incorrectness. CoV for

ovangle:

11-21-2008 09:26:46 UTC

Actually, CoV again against

Rule 1.7 specifies that the GNDT may only be updated in a manner permitted by the current ruleset.

Rule 1.8 specifies there is only a single narrator, so unless you first deposed Yoda as narrator (which you didn’t), updating the GNDT to make yourself also a narrator is prohibited.

Soz

spikebrennan:

11-21-2008 13:33:08 UTC

against
Having the occupation “narrator” doesn’t mean that you are the capital-n narrator for core rule purposes.  Besides, being narrator doesn’t enable you to declare victory, it’s the otherway around

Purplebeard:

11-21-2008 13:46:48 UTC

against

Hello Sailor:

11-21-2008 14:10:18 UTC

against What sb said:  even if the occupation “narrator” is misinterpreted as being the same as the “narrator” in the core rules, that doesn’t imply that you’ve achieved victory; nothing in the Ruleset suggests such an implication.

Yoda:

11-21-2008 15:02:29 UTC

against

Clucky:

11-21-2008 15:09:58 UTC

against

Rodlen:

11-21-2008 15:22:35 UTC

against

Oze:

11-21-2008 16:06:39 UTC

against Per spikebrennan and Hello Sailor