Call for Judgment: Improper Enactment
Quorum of AGAINST votes, final vote 8-0 -Darth
Adminned at 03 Dec 2009 14:39:49 UTC
The section of Proposal: Doppleganger called “Part 1” has no game effect and should not have been enacted by Darth Cliche. Furthermore, Darth Cliche neglected to properly follow Rule 1.5 Enactment by failing to “mark his name, and report the final tally of votes”. Darth Cliche’s enactment of Part 1 should be removed from the Ruleset. Part 2 can stay, as it has a game effect, conceptually.
Basically, spikebrennan screwed up and didn’t follow Rule 1.1 Ruleset and Gamestate when he used the term “the list of spells in the Ruleset”. If you check the comments for the proposal, you can see many people agreeing that this is 100% true and not in dispute. Darth Cliche seems to be VERY interested in abiding by the rules strictly where *I* am concerned, but content to flagrantly violate them himself and ignore the violations of others when it suits his needs. This is, in a word, unacceptable. Either we sign on to have people follow the rules and we’re playing a game of Nomic, or we just ignore the rules when we want (or, at least the people who are in charge get to ignore them) and we’re playing some other game that Darth Cliche seems to have invented.
Part 2 would properly add text to the ruleset, even if that text, at present, doesn’t do much of anything.