Friday, August 23, 2019

Call for Judgment: Itdoesnotmattersoherehaveaport

Times out, 2-2. Failed by pokes.

Adminned at 25 Aug 2019 11:52:08 UTC

Change the allegiance of port Mornington to Blue. Give derrick 1 treasure as a minor recompense.

Comments

Farsight:

23-08-2019 06:52:53 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

23-08-2019 08:01:15 UTC

against Disagree that this also deserves compensation: with CfJs, Derrick is being allowed to take an invisible move outside of the regular Watch system, where rival players would have been acting on the belief that Derrick was still at Auld Anchorage. Derrick has the advantage here.

TyGuy6:

23-08-2019 08:17:26 UTC

It’s not invisible. He’s already there.

TyGuy6:

23-08-2019 08:26:46 UTC

Hmm, but sure, he wasn’t there for a full turn to take the port. And one treasure could tip the balance. Might even be a last straw. Might send someone over the edge, hmm?

Kevan: he/him

23-08-2019 08:55:36 UTC

I just mean that when players were choosing and submitting orders during Watch Seven, we all thought Derrick was staying at Auld Anchorage and factored that in accordingly. (Derrick only pointed out the oversight half an hour before the end of Watch Seven, giving nobody any time to react to the revelation.)

Appearing to be in one place but actually being in another is a good thing, not something that needs compensation.

derrick: he/him

23-08-2019 12:50:23 UTC

The timing was not intentional. I was on vacation and trying squeeze in visits every 48 hours. I don’t think I need to reward me, I’m just trying to make the moves that were my obvious intention without holding up the game.

for I suppose.

pokes:

25-08-2019 11:51:43 UTC

against Now that derrick is idle.