Tuesday, August 10, 2010

Proposal: Loophole Slayer

Self-killed. -coppro

Adminned at 11 Aug 2010 22:14:36 UTC

Amend Rule 1.3 by replacing the list with:

  • A Citizen cannot submit a non-Core Proposal if that Citizen already has two or more non-Core Proposals pending.
  • A Citizen cannot submit a Proposal if that Citizen already has three or more Proposals pending.
  • A Citizen cannot submit a Proposal if that Citizen has already submitted two or more Proposals that day.

Replace the definition of Core Proposal with

A Proposal whose changes are limited to the creation, deletion, and/or amendment of core rules and/or the glossary, and/or renaming, banning, and/or the granting or removing of admin status from one or more Citizens.

Currently, you can’t submit a Core Proposal if you have one proposal of each type pending. That means that they merely need to add some random facet to it, maybe correcting a typo in a dynastic rule, and it is non-core and thus legal. Also, the definition of Core Proposal could use a little bit of widening.

Comments

lilomar:

08-10-2010 06:07:20 UTC

for

Bucky:

08-10-2010 06:49:48 UTC

against  on decreasing the proposals-per-day cap by 1

lilomar:

08-10-2010 06:51:24 UTC

Can’t post if they have already posted two is the same as three a day.

scshunt:

08-10-2010 07:12:26 UTC

oops, that was a typo on my part. I’m not so enamored with the three-a-day limit that I’ll self-kill, though.

lilomar:

08-10-2010 07:22:02 UTC

/doh. No it isn’t.
CoV against per Bucky

Kevan:

08-10-2010 07:44:50 UTC

Although unintuitively worded, the current rule does resolve to “one Core and two non-Core per 48 hours” if you work it out on the back of an envelope.

against

Keba:

08-10-2010 13:02:52 UTC

against

Purplebeard:

08-10-2010 18:07:37 UTC

against

Qwazukee:

08-10-2010 19:46:05 UTC

for

Darknight:

08-11-2010 01:38:49 UTC

against

Wakukee:

08-11-2010 02:27:06 UTC

against

scshunt:

08-11-2010 22:54:42 UTC

against s/k