Friday, May 15, 2009

Proposal: Out for medical reasons

Cannot be enacted with 14 votes against. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 16 May 2009 12:22:47 UTC

Create a new rule, titled Health, with the following text:

There exists a statistic called Health, which is tracked in the GNDT.  Each Contestant starts with 10 Health.  If a Contestant has 0 health, their health is immediately set to 5 and their Status is set to Out.

Comments

Kevan:

05-15-2009 18:07:45 UTC

imperial Along with hitting each other with pipes, this doesn’t really fit with what I was expecting from a reality TV series theme. But it’s ais523’s call.

Bucky:

05-15-2009 18:18:04 UTC

imperial As Kevan.  I’d be fine with it, but only if the main way to change someone’s Health isn’t beating them up.  Poisoning is fine.  Baseball bats aren’t.

Rodlen:

05-15-2009 18:21:41 UTC

Yeah, I don’t exactly want random violence, but maybe there could be challenges that would decrease health…or something.

Devenger:

05-15-2009 18:25:01 UTC

against not appropriate for the theme at all, I don’t think.

Rodlen:

05-15-2009 18:28:17 UTC

I’ve seen people leave reality TV shows for medical reasons quite a few times…

TAE:

05-15-2009 18:28:52 UTC

imperial Usally when someone attcks someone else on a reality TV show doesn’t the person doing the attacking get kicked off, not the person getting hurt?

SingularByte:

05-15-2009 18:30:20 UTC

against

Quazie:

05-15-2009 18:58:49 UTC

for Why can’t this be a bit exaggerated?

Rodlen:

05-15-2009 19:23:06 UTC

Ratings, people, ratings!  Fighting makes good TV!

Rodlen:

05-15-2009 19:29:14 UTC

And so do medical problems!

firefaux:

05-15-2009 20:04:47 UTC

imperial

Darknight:

05-15-2009 20:46:48 UTC

imperial

Klisz:

05-15-2009 21:03:10 UTC

for

Qwazukee:

05-15-2009 21:07:23 UTC

imperial I think this would create a mechanic for Stingray bites, if nothing else.

Influenza:

05-15-2009 21:22:05 UTC

against I’m too paranoid of poison to vote ‘for’ to this proposal ;-;

Yoda:

05-15-2009 22:25:46 UTC

for might turn out to be interesting

meh,  imperial

Bucky:

05-16-2009 03:26:42 UTC

CoV against .

delta:

05-16-2009 06:41:29 UTC

against Per Kevan.

ais523:

05-16-2009 09:19:50 UTC

against When reality TV shows gain rules like this, the police end up getting called in. And that would be problematic, because I don’t know if they know where the bunker is either.

Psychotipath:

05-16-2009 12:25:14 UTC

against Per Influenza , adding: gratuitous violence, assault, murder, drug/alcohol abuse, etc.etc.etc.