Average of active Orcs? Of number of players?

Shouldn’t the final clause be unconditional and not in a rule, like “set Purity of all Orcs to 100”?

Seems a bit too complicated to me…

Per quirck. I unidle, quorum doesn’t change.

Broken phrases aside, I think, considering the victory eligibility bit, it should default to 100 period? I’m also not sure if the scale should be so large.

This seems easy enough to either pass and then patch, or just repropose entirely, if people like the mechanic. ...Which, doesn’t seem to be the case.

For the record, “defaulting to the average of active Orcs,” should have been “defaulting to the average Purity of all Orcs”. (You don’t need to specify active, because of Rule 1.2.1 Idle Orcs: “For the purposes of all Gamestate and the Ruleset, excluding Rules “Ruleset and Gamestate”, “Orcs”, “Dynasties”, “Fair Play” and any of those Rules’ subrules, Idle Orcs are not counted as Orcs”)

Yes, it should have read “defaulting to the average Purity of all Orcs”.

The defaulting to an average was intended on stopping unidling players from swooping in and claiming victory :)

I don’t think the last clause is unclear; how should initial states be specified if different than the default? If it’s not in a rule how does it have any force?

Proposals specify changes to not only ruleset but also gamestate, so it is ok to say “Set Purity of all Orcs to 100” (like here). Rules are needed for something more permanent, or for something that should be done not immediately (like here or here).

Ah. I understand.

Is there a reason to not post your first comment as a Note:? I’m happy to make clarifying changes such as these…

Not really. At the time there was only one proposal, so you could immediately SK/repropose it, so I didn’t see any harm in beginning the vote. Besides, the proposal was already 8 hours old, add time to edit it, and the time for actual voting would be reduced by quarter?

As RaichuKFM said, there is always an option to vote FOR the proposal and later put up a fix, but it seems noone chose this way (including RaichuKFM himself)

You can, of course, make a new Proposal with a reworked version of the rule, though the reaction to the idea itself didn’t seem the best.