Saturday, March 14, 2009

Proposal: Scene correction, proposal version

Self-killed, failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 16 Mar 2009 23:34:51 UTC

In 2.2 acts, change

The description of a Scene requires a Title (text which cannot exceed five words), a Script (a text summary of the scene which cannot exceed 25 words), and the Scene’s Body Count. Scripters are encouraged to write a script that reflects the Body Count they have rolled. The Bodies statistic of a Scripter who creates a Scene increases by the Body Count of the Scene they create.

To

The description of a Scene requires a Title (text which cannot exceed five words), a Script (a text summary of the scene which cannot exceed 25 words), and the Scene’s Body Count. Scripters are encouraged to write a script that reflects the Body Count they have rolled. The Bodies statistic of a Scripter who creates a Scene increases by the Body Count of the Scene they create. Attempts to create Scenes that do not follow this format shall not count as Scenes for any purposes. Comments that are not Scenes cannot retroactively become Scenes.

 

Comments

Rodlen:

03-14-2009 23:13:25 UTC

for

Qwazukee:

03-14-2009 23:16:02 UTC

Meh, I think this was fine as a CfJ, it’s exactly what CfJs are for. The second-to-last sentence doesn’t need to be in the Ruleset, in particular. But the last sentecne does, so for.

Darknight:

03-15-2009 04:11:48 UTC

imperial

Igthorn:

03-15-2009 07:18:02 UTC

imperial

Kevan:

03-15-2009 10:25:16 UTC

against Penultimate sentence is redundant, and editing comments is already illegal under Rule 3.6.

Devenger:

03-15-2009 12:41:20 UTC

against

Reasons above, plus this will break if the word count changing proposal ( http://blognomic.com/archive/word_count_mk_2/ ) passes, which it is set to do (because the text you are changing will no longer exist in the same form).

Klisz:

03-15-2009 18:58:16 UTC

against  per Kev and Dev.

SingularByte:

03-15-2009 21:59:22 UTC

against Okay. Self kill.