Friday, January 16, 2009

Proposal: So Close…

Vetoed—arth

Adminned at 16 Jan 2009 13:14:24 UTC

If a guess is extremely close to the actual theme and the staff member who made the guess still has at least one guess remaining, then the writer may post the words “follow up” in his comment on it. If he does this, than no other staff member may post a guess until either 24 hours have passed or the player who made the extremely close guess has posted a new guess.

Comments

SingularByte:

01-16-2009 13:53:10 UTC

If you actually defined what counts as ‘extremely close’ or at least said that it’s up to the writer instead of leaving it vague, I’d vote FOR.  against

Wooble:

01-16-2009 15:25:52 UTC

imperial

Rodlen:

01-16-2009 15:36:42 UTC

against

Amnistar:

01-16-2009 16:27:02 UTC

imperial

It has potential…right now though I’m not sure that I want to be able to lock people out of guessing…

arthexis:

01-16-2009 17:04:31 UTC

against

Klisz:

01-16-2009 17:10:55 UTC

against

Yoda:

01-16-2009 17:59:31 UTC

against Also, this doesn’t create or modify a rule.

Wooden Squid:

01-16-2009 18:21:53 UTC

against This is too vague.

Darknight:

01-16-2009 19:12:30 UTC

against

Wakukee:

01-16-2009 21:05:27 UTC

against  self-kill

arthexis:

01-16-2009 21:13:58 UTC

veto Doing you a favor.