Monday, November 22, 2010

Proposal: The brain rules!

Passes at 12-1. -Purplebeard

Adminned at 24 Nov 2010 05:13:56 UTC

Create a rule titled “The brain rules” with the following text:

A student who has a grade of A+ in each subject achieves victory.

Straight forward. This should bring some action, as disrupting and distracting are required to stop people from improving their grades in lessons. Also some tactics are required involving prefect status and the heads of houses.

Comments

Greytyphoon:

22-11-2010 15:53:06 UTC

for

FuzzyLogic:

22-11-2010 15:53:38 UTC

for Sure why not

Josh: Observer he/they

22-11-2010 19:52:24 UTC

against Ehh. Not a very satisfactory victory mechanic given that achieving it is one part grinding to one part crapshoot.

Darknight: he/him

22-11-2010 19:53:13 UTC

imperial

Brendan: he/him

22-11-2010 19:57:05 UTC

I’ve thought about this myself, but it seems likely to end up in the kind of annoying kingmaker scenario I dislike in board games.  “Someone Distract him, he’s going to win!”  Still, I’ll give it a qualified for, since it can’t hurt to have a second victory condition when the existing one is equally crapshootable.

Kevan: he/him

22-11-2010 20:08:57 UTC

for

William:

22-11-2010 21:30:17 UTC

for

Roujo: he/him

22-11-2010 23:06:24 UTC

for Per Brendan.

macgeorge:

22-11-2010 23:31:09 UTC

for

Richard:

23-11-2010 05:07:21 UTC

for

Alecto:

23-11-2010 08:11:24 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

23-11-2010 08:41:34 UTC

for

Blacky:

24-11-2010 11:29:33 UTC

Thinking about it for the last two days, and like it less and less. However, the feelings are not so strong that I would S/k it, which is also due to the overwhelming majority of FORs.