Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Votes on Act #1

Now that we have the Best in Show rule, any Scripter who contributed to Act #1 can vote on the best and worst scenes from it, to decide who gains and loses popularity among the writing team. Comment on this post with your votes.

Comments

Kevan:

03-17-2009 10:10:45 UTC

Best Scene: Recurring Villain.
Worst Scene: RODLEN WUZ HARE.

Gnauga:

03-17-2009 12:11:56 UTC

Best Scene: Backup
Worst Scene: Crossfire

SingularByte:

03-17-2009 12:17:24 UTC

Best Scene: Too Quiet
Worst Scene: Politics Loses

Klisz:

03-17-2009 15:02:53 UTC

Best Scene: Going Down.
Worst Scene: Crossfire.

Rodlen:

03-17-2009 17:07:45 UTC

Best Scene: Too Quiet
Worst Scene: Crossfire.

Crossfire was just too cliched for me.

Influenza:

03-17-2009 18:22:22 UTC

Best Scene: Bam!
Worst Scene: Useless Cops

Bam! and the dirt is gone!

Devenger:

03-17-2009 19:14:51 UTC

Best Scene: Recurring Villain
Worst Scene: RODLAN WUZ HARE

Qwazukee:

03-17-2009 19:44:47 UTC

Best Scene: Crossfire
Worst Scene: A small family.

Darknight:

03-17-2009 20:03:51 UTC

Best Scene: Recurring Villain
Worst Scene: RODLAN WUZ HARE

Jupiter:

03-17-2009 22:15:49 UTC

Best Scene: Recurring Villain
Worst Scene: ROLDAN WUZ HARE

gill_smoke:

03-17-2009 22:35:25 UTC

Was there really 104 bodies in the 14 scenes of the “Prolog”?

Kevan:

03-17-2009 22:46:58 UTC

There were a lot of rolls above five.

4+7+10+7+2+10+8+7+6+9+10+4+6+5+9 = 104

Gnauga:

03-17-2009 23:04:08 UTC

Mr. RNG loves us.

Rodlen:

03-18-2009 01:15:13 UTC

Luckily for me, Jupiter voted against a non-existant scene.  RODLAN, not ROLDAN.

Rodlen:

03-18-2009 01:15:52 UTC

Oh, and Kevan, you voted against RODLEN.

Wow.  Typos love me.

Qwazukee:

03-18-2009 02:48:06 UTC

So far:

Best Scene: Recurring Villain (4)
Too Quiet (2)
Backup (1)
Going Down (1)
Bam! (1)
Crossfire (1)

Worst Scene: RODLAN WUZ HARE (including alternate spellings) (4)
Crossfire (3)
Politics Loses (1)
Useless Cops (1)
A small family. (1)

Altharis:

03-18-2009 06:59:08 UTC

Best Scene: The Cops Never Win
(Reason: Could be put together really well, especially if done evasive gun-fu style.)

Worst: Crossfire
(Reason: Almost the same opening premise as The Cops Never Win, but with a poorer execution.)

Kevan:

03-18-2009 09:27:21 UTC

We’re just “voting on which Scene”, we aren’t “stating the exact title of which Scene”.

Rodlen:

03-18-2009 18:45:47 UTC

However, you have to vote on scenes that actually exist.  As “ROLDAN WUZ HARE” and “RODLEN WUZ HARE” don’t actually exist, they wouldn’t be counted.  And, as obvious typos can only be fixed in the ruleset…

Bucky:

03-18-2009 18:51:35 UTC

It’s still obious which scene they voted for, whether they spelled it right or not

Influenza:

03-18-2009 18:52:05 UTC

there are no exact rules on the voting process. It does not state that you have to vote for both parts in one comment, also if ‘RODLAN WUZ HARE’ and ‘RODLEN WUZ HARE’ are not scenes, then they have not yet placed their vote for a worst scene, since they have not voted for a scene to be the worst. in my opinion there is nothing to stop them commenting their vote for worst scene using the ‘correct’ spelling.

Kevan:

03-18-2009 18:56:17 UTC

So long as it’s unambiguous which scene the Scripter being voted for, it’s a vote. I could have voted for “that scene with the monocle” - that sort of vote would be a bit annoying to tally, but there’s nothing in the rule that says I have to give the Scene name.

Your own votes of “Too Quiet” (actual scene had a full stop at the end) and “Crossfire.” (actual scene had no full stop) are also fine.

Qwazukee:

03-18-2009 19:33:04 UTC

We should have a CfJ about it! I miss the days when Call for Judgement ruled BlogNomic . . . actually I hated several things about those days, especially when anonymous CfJ got abused so much that we had to eliminate him. But it all feels nostalgic now.

Devenger:

03-18-2009 19:45:40 UTC

Rodlen, the votes against you are valid, else I open a big can of whoop-ass the next time you attempt to create a Scene. You know what I’m saying, people who have read the Ruleset carefully enough.

I declare voting to be closed.

The best scene was Recurring Villain by Gnauga (4). The worst scenes were RODLAN WUZ HARE by Rodlen (4), and Crossfire by SingularByte (4). Adjusting Popularity now…