Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Proposal: Over 9000

Timed out and passes, 7-0, but has no effect due to rule 2.1. Josh

Adminned at 21 Feb 2013 15:43:16 UTC

Amend Rule 1.4.2 on line “It has a number of FOR Votes that exceed or equal Quorum, has been open for voting for at least 12 hours, and has not been Vetoed or Self-Killed.”


to read:

“It has a number of FOR Votes that is greater than the number of AGAINST votes and exceeds or equals Quorum, has been open for voting for at least 12 hours, and has not been Vetoed or Self-Killed.

As Purplebeard points out - there is a truly passable scam that can be a problem in general.  With PC, The number of For votes can exceed quorum, but be less than the number of AGAINST votes.

Comments

nqeron:

19-02-2013 15:19:05 UTC

Alternatively, I can deliberate this and make it a Dynastic rule instead.

Purplebeard:

19-02-2013 15:27:23 UTC

for Nah, this belongs in the Core Rules.

I pointed this out to nqeron after I had asked them to vote AGAINST on Right Field, so that I could enact it before anyone could respond. They declined, thus denying me my boyhood dream of enacting a failing proposal. :(

Larrytheturtle:

19-02-2013 15:49:48 UTC

for

scshunt:

19-02-2013 15:55:30 UTC

I’ll leave this proposal in since the Dynasty may end, there’s no queue to clear yet, and it could be Deliberated, but I’ll note that the Core Rules can’t be amended by proposal in this Dynasty.

RaichuKFM: she/her

19-02-2013 16:56:23 UTC

for

Larrytheturtle:

19-02-2013 20:15:48 UTC

for

Skju:

19-02-2013 22:49:28 UTC

for with scshunt’s note

MurphEngineer:

21-02-2013 15:38:25 UTC

for I can see this becoming a problem at some point if it hasn’t already.

Klisz:

21-02-2013 18:49:31 UTC

for