Saturday, October 10, 2009

Proposal: [Theft] 217.. Hike!

Fails 9-5 yuri_dragon_17
-2 to DK

Adminned at 12 Oct 2009 12:38:08 UTC

Create a rule called “Nomic 217” with the following text.

The Motto of Blognomic is this: “Legislating from the bench is the
most efficient way to do it. If something essential would be broken,
it instead isn’t. Spirit trumps letter.” The Motto of Blognomic, like
its rules, has full jurisdiction over the things defined by the rules
of Blognomic.

Had a bad roll and got me nomic 217. Kinda a dead nomic with rather blah rules. My poor points lol. Changed up afew words from the original

Comments

Ienpw III:

10-10-2009 05:55:09 UTC

for

Qwazukee:

10-10-2009 06:49:50 UTC

for

arthexis:

10-10-2009 07:42:23 UTC

against Too far reaching

Kevan:

10-10-2009 08:09:30 UTC

against

Darknight:

10-10-2009 08:10:23 UTC

well as I said, I kinda got shafted on the roll

Kevan:

10-10-2009 08:10:40 UTC

If we encounter any dead Nomics in the “ActiveStatus” list, incidentally, it’d be useful if we updated the nomic.net wiki to say that they were actually dead.

Excalabur:

10-10-2009 10:38:39 UTC

for for Kevan. 

against for the proposal.

Bucky:

10-10-2009 14:50:39 UTC

against

Josh:

10-10-2009 15:37:48 UTC

against

spikebrennan:

10-10-2009 17:48:55 UTC

against

Klisz:

10-10-2009 20:21:37 UTC

for  for  for  for  for

Ienpw III:

10-10-2009 20:56:04 UTC

It *does* describe Blognomic.

ais523:

10-11-2009 11:43:40 UTC

for because it describes BlogNomic pretty well. (I’m aware of how Nomic 217 went, by the way; after a while it became rather unclear what was a rule and what wasn’t, and anyway nobody was keeping track of them.)

Oze:

10-11-2009 13:52:31 UTC

against

Bucky:

10-11-2009 20:59:34 UTC

CoV for

Ienpw III:

10-12-2009 00:36:25 UTC

Currently 6-6.

Darknight:

10-12-2009 00:42:22 UTC

I’m shocked that its getting even a split vote

Wakukee:

10-12-2009 01:23:25 UTC

against

Oranjer:

10-12-2009 01:40:09 UTC

against Would this not allow someone to argue about the spirit vs. the letter of “spirit trumps letter”?

Ienpw III:

10-12-2009 17:35:58 UTC

CoV against for speed. Failing 9-5.