Fweep - Don’t flirt if you can’t follow through
Fweep overturned, 0-3. Unfortunately - and please correct me if I’m wrong on this - I can’t see any evidence in the GNDT to suggest that Prince Anduril actually gave coppro the foul that the fweep required him to. As there was no “awarded foul” this can’t be transferred. This leaves me in an odd spot - I can either assume that the foul was passively awarded in the gamestate and that the GNDT simply doesn’t reflect this, and proceed on that basis, although that requires an intent on PA’s part that cannot be proven to exist and which leaves me liable to a follow-up fweep; or I can do the most I can without incurring any liability myself, which is to observe that PA’s actions have resulted in illegal gamestate that should probably be resolved through other means, and encourage the use of a CfJ to regulate the awarding of any due fouls. I’ve gone with the latter. -Josh
Adminned at 17 Aug 2011 14:46:41 UTC
Since someone needs to propose this and the Slip and Slide Suicide CfJ here looks like it might fail, I propose a new Fweep simply requesting that coppro be given a foul, without reference to his actions being reverted.
scshunt:
This is not a legal fweep since it does not detail the nature of the foul.