Thursday, May 21, 2009

Proposal: Unnecessary Way to Come Back

Timed out. Enacted by Clucky.

Adminned at 23 May 2009 20:42:09 UTC

Remove the text “Whenever a proposal is enacted, if the Contestant who authored it is at that time an Outsider, that Outsider becomes an Insider; the admin who enacts the proposal is responsible for updating the GNDT accordingly.” from rule 2.1 “In or out?”.

We don’t want perfectly good proposals failing just because they are made by an outsider.  Also, if someone resigns at least 24 hours before their proposal passes, they get an easy 1 fame.

Comments

Ienpw III:

05-21-2009 20:23:33 UTC

for

Qwazukee:

05-21-2009 20:24:42 UTC

for Ya, I never particularly liked that one in the first place.

Klisz:

05-21-2009 20:26:56 UTC

for

Bucky:

05-21-2009 20:31:06 UTC

imperial .  ais’s call

Kevan:

05-21-2009 21:16:49 UTC

for

ais523:

05-21-2009 21:18:52 UTC

for based on the exploit Yoda points out. We have better ways now. (And I made it a subproposal in the initial rule for a reason.)

Kevan:

05-21-2009 21:26:32 UTC

for

Kevan:

05-21-2009 21:28:03 UTC

Plus some muttering about subproposals only requiring half of quorum to be in favour of them, leading to repeals like this.

ais523:

05-21-2009 22:03:17 UTC

@Kevan: I think the subproposal was at or near quorum anyway; the repeal is because the rules have changed around the original proposal, meaning that we’re adapting to a change in circumstances.

Rodlen:

05-22-2009 00:29:22 UTC

for

Darknight:

05-22-2009 01:58:34 UTC

for

smith:

05-22-2009 02:25:07 UTC

imperial

arthexis:

05-22-2009 04:11:25 UTC

for

delta:

05-22-2009 08:41:29 UTC

for Like Qwaz I didn’t like that rule to begin with.

SingularByte:

05-22-2009 08:53:59 UTC

for

spikebrennan:

05-22-2009 13:49:16 UTC

for

Qwazukee:

05-23-2009 04:25:51 UTC

13-0

TAE:

05-23-2009 19:25:32 UTC

for

Clucky:

05-23-2009 20:41:21 UTC

for