Friday, April 26, 2024

The Darkroom

Post-dynastic washup thread.

Declaration of Victory: Photo Finish

Open for 12 hours with more than 2/3 of votes in favour including the Observer. Enacted 5-0 by Kevan.

Adminned at 26 Apr 2024 21:43:56 UTC

With 4 Awards I have achieved victory. My Private Criteria and their salts were, in chronological order:

“Satisfies the text of my 1st secret key. 512”, “Satisfies the text of my 2nd secret key. 104”, “Satisfies the text of my 3rd secret key. 826”, “Satisfies the text of my 4th secret key. 912”, “Satisfies the text of my 5th secret key. 783”, “Satisfies the text of my 2nd secret key. 953”, “Satisfies the text of my 5th secret key. 173”, “Satisfies the text of my 54th secret key. 511”, “Satisfies the text of my 29th secret key. 451”, “Satisfies the text of my 386th secret key. 613”, “Satisfies the text of my 853rd secret key. 271”, “Satisfies the text of my 3716th secret key. 523”, “Satisfies the text of my 3727th secret key. 124”, “Satisfies the text of my 1731st secret key. 436”, “Satisfies the text of my 7510th secret key. 415”, “Satisfies the text of my 9264th secret key. 774”, “Doesn’t contain a Mornington Crescent mug. 523”, “Doesn’t contain a Mornington Crescent mug. 124”, “Doesn’t contain a Mornington Crescent mug. 436”, “Doesn’t contain a Mornington Crescent mug. 415”, “Doesn’t contain a Mornington Crescent mug. 774”, “Doesn’t contain Bank tube station. 126”, “Doesn’t contain Euston tube station. 361”, “Doesn’t contain Morden tube station. 751”, “Doesn’t contain Chalk Farm tube station. 925”, “Doesn’t contain Balham tube station. 651”, “Contains a liftable manmade object. bkf”, “Neither the sky nor the sea is visible. wh6”, “Contains a painted surface (but not blue). dha”, “Contains something brown and/or striped. i8y”, “Camera is clearly angled downwards. kxj”, “Contains a tree, twig or playing card. g9q”, “Contains glass or clear plastic. ba8”, “Contains a crisp shadow or clear reflection. ba9”, “Contains an object at least 50m away. 6nj”, “Player name is neither horizontal nor red. 86h”

Award: Conceptual Balance

I claim the Conceptual Balance award: at this point on 22 April I had a Criteria at 4/4, from snaps 29 through 36.

Thursday, April 25, 2024

Guess: Kevan: Water

I think I will make an extraordinarily unlikely but somewhat topical guess:

Kevan is one of your criteria:

snap contains water?

Wednesday, April 24, 2024

Proposal: Guessing Game 2.0

In the rule “Guesses” replace the text “Make a story post to the blog clearly declaring the name of the Targeted Seeker, and what the guesser thinks one of their Private Criteria are” with this text:

Make a story post to the blog containing each the following items: the name of the Targeted Seeker, text that uniquely identifies a single existing Authentic Shot posted within the last 48 hours where the Targeted Seeker has not yet responded to that post and the guesser is not the author of that post, and a number between 1 and 4 inclusive that the guesser thinks is the number of Private Criteria that the named Authentic Shot will satisfy for the Targeted Seeker.

In the same rule, replace the steps for the atomic action Resolving the Guess with the following steps:

* If the number mentioned in the guess is the same as the number of Private Criteria that is satisfied for the Targeted Seeker for that Authentic Shot, respond to the post with a for, reduce their own Score by the Exposure of each of the Private Criteria that is satisfied by that Authentic Shot, and increase the score of the Guesser by the same amount, and then remove each of that Private Criteria from the Target’s private criteria list (resetting its satisfying and unsatisfying counts to zero in the process)
* If the guess is not the same as the number of Private Criteria that is satisfied for the Targeted Seeker for that Authentic Shot, respond to the post with a against

Hopefully this will address the comments from the previous iteration of the Guessing Game proposal. Please do look for holes in this. Suggestions are welcome to word this more concisely if possible. That’s one thing I often struggle with.

Proposal: Conjunction Junction

Timed out 3 votes to 2. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 26 Apr 2024 09:20:28 UTC

In Criteria, replace “Private criteria may only refer to and be verified by the contents of the shot. Private criteria may not refer to things such as the date, other criteria, the contents of other documents or the thoughts, opinions or feelings of any Seeker.” with:

Private criteria may only refer to and be verified by the contents of the shot. Private criteria may not refer to things such as the date, other criteria, the contents of other documents or the thoughts, opinions or feelings of any Seeker. Private criteria may not use the conjunctions “and”, “or”, “and/or”, “nor” to combine multiple shot conditions.

This proposal disallows concatenated criteria.  For example: “Snap contains something black or stripped”.  Criteria with more than one condition make “guessing” almost impossible. This also outlaws absurdly long criteria with many conditions.

Monday, April 22, 2024

Personal Criteria

As it has been 48 hours, I now have a Personal Criteria of Bird.

Personal Criteria

As it has been 48 hours, I now have a Personal Criteria of Bird.

Story Post: Upgrade Request: Snap 37

Exceeded quorum, 5-0. Processed by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 23 Apr 2024 14:27:30 UTC

I believe that Snap 037 Bounty meets the upgrade benchmark for:

“A Snap, posted after 19 April, to which the Observer has responded saying that he finds it aesthetically pleasing”

Proposal: I forgot how fast this game was

Timed out, 3-1 with 1 DEF. Enacted by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 24 Apr 2024 18:32:52 UTC

Grant all players who comment or vote on this proposal 5 score for participation

I don’t want to go idle but I probably deserve to

Mentmore

JonathanDark will act as Xebec’s mentor.

Award: Grand Prix in Advertising Photography

I claim the “Grand Prix in Advertising Photography” for guessing another Seeker’s Criterion.

Award: Fine Art Photographer of the Year

With more than 200 Score I claim “Fine Art Photographer of the Year”.

Criterion Refresh

I refresh my Criterion of “Camera is clearly angled downwards. kxj” (80494b98cac922f620f8a26ed125439706f8aafeb8576017f95822c0faa712f0)

Last criteria reset for a bit

Hopefully my last criteria reset for a bit:

Contains the username Kevan or Josh
b5a2f7e3ede0a0d08cdac898256f79867dd35e723fd360e22cca8a67f6d8e9ea

Story Post: Snap 038: Carnivore in the Garden Redeux

A few more criteria changes

Changing my 3rd and 5th Private Criteria (4th was reset due to Kevan’s correct Guess):

Contains an even number of letters on paper
31cca6dfee161290c417b0b6ac2c631ab7c5a25dd4abf284cd57e867663334f5

Contains something blue
a335b14fd8ccc861b2b8f26f0e454047d24e17c83c90e1b5c595c3eb1b8b9e54

JonathanDark Claims Conceptual Balance For Real

For real this time: I claim Conceptual Balance due to my 1st Private Criteria which has a Satisfying score of 4 and an Unsatisfying score of 4, where those scores were obtained from 8 contiguous Authentic Shots all taken after 8 April 2024

Sunday, April 21, 2024

Story Post: Snap 037: Bounty

I would like to become a player

Hi BlogNomic, I’m Xebec, I would like to become a player.

handle on discord is @radioactivecauliflowerstew. Got here from Infinite Nomic, my name on there is “google” (using something slightly less confusing for here but on second thoughts having two different names might be more confusing). Anyway, hello. Looking forward to meet everyone.

Story Post: A Guess

I guess that one of Jonathan Dark’s Private Criteria is that the photo must contain some water.

JonathanDark Claims Conceptual Balance (illegal)

I claim the Conceptual Balance award for my 5th Private Criteria which has a Satisfying score of 4 and an Unsatisfying score of 4, where those scores were obtained from 8 contiguous Authentic Shots all taken after 8 April 2024

Claimed too soon, please ignore.

Story Post: Snap 037: Carnivore in the Garden (illegal do not respond to this)

(Snap removed because it was taken too soon. I need to wait until April 22 UTC.)

Criteria Changeout

Changing my second criteria:

Contains the sky at night
77683063a39b2af4f0fd5e0db69c4bad7aa4307ed80e5a5b42fb4ebdbf62c31b

@NadNavillus: note that it was “the sky at night”, which is not equivalent to “night” or “dark” because you could take Shots of either without having the night sky in them.

Story Post: Snap 036: Beach

Saturday, April 20, 2024

Personal Criteria Request for Juniper

I nominate myself for a Personal Criteria.

Friday, April 19, 2024

Criteria Refresh

I reset my Criteria of “Contains something brown and/or striped. i8y” (67e1c5415087d464335a87445835adb3900aecf9483bbfc21137e54c43d51399)

Proposal: The Bench Acknowledges

Timed out, 3-0. Enacted by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 21 Apr 2024 18:59:22 UTC

Add the following to the list of Upgrade Criteria in the rule Upgrades:

* Post three consecutive Snaps each of which was posted at the earliest possible point (to the nearest day) that they could have been under the poster’s Development Interval at the time of posting
* A Snap which was provably taken in a different time zone from a previous Snap taken by the same Seeker
* A Snap, posted after 19 April, to which the Observer has responded saying that he finds it aesthetically pleasing (for the purposes of the rule No Cooperations, this may be considered a co-operative mechanism, although the Observer is encouraged to evaluate each Snap on its aesthetic merits rather than persuing any actual tacit or explicit co-operation)

At present, Excellence in War Photography is impossible as a Development Bonus of 3 requires 6 upgrades and only 5 are available. Just rounding out the list a little.

Proposal: Freeze Frame

Timed out 3 votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 21 Apr 2024 15:28:23 UTC

In “Awards”, replace “where those scores were obtained from the 8 most recent contiguous Authentic Shots” with:-

where those scores were obtained from 8 contiguous Authentic Shots all taken after 8 April 2024

The current “most recent” wording is a little on the fragile side; somebody who would qualify for the Award can have it denied by any player happening to post a ninth photo before they have a chance to claim it. The 8 April cutoff will include NadNavillus’s recent attainment but no earlier ones.