Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Proposal: I love making stuff up

cannot be enacted without cov, final vote 1-2-8—Yoda

Adminned at 22 Oct 2008 15:45:27 UTC

Add the following to sub-rule “List of Valid Items”:

Rock: A hard and heavy rock that can be used for throwing and smashing. When used in battle, roll DICE3 and on a 1, the next time during this battle that the opponent takes any type of Damage, that Damage is considered Crushing, then regardless of the roll result remove the Rock from your items.

Paper: A declaration of truce that will bring dishonor to Clansmen that dares attack you. As long as you have Paper in your inventory, other Clansmen that Damage you loose DICE3 their honor every time they do. If the damage is Crushing, the honor lost is multiplied by four.

Scissors: A primitive but still sharp double blade, useful for slicing through most materials. You may use it at anytime you would deal Damage. If you do, instead of dealing Damage you may remove any one Item from the damaged Clansmen, except for Items called Rock, then remove Scissors from your items.

Each Clansmen who voted on this proposal may once, within 24 hours of the passing of this proposal, choose one Item from the “List of Valid Items” and add it to their Items if they are currently holding no Items. If they don’t choose an Item, they may increase their honor by 2 instead.

Comments

Rodlen:

10-22-2008 05:20:25 UTC

imperial Scissors is a bit overpowered (Paper beats rock, rock beats scissors, scissors beats everything but rock)

arthexis:

10-22-2008 06:21:21 UTC

Nothing beats rock! (True: even with Paper, it still hurts)

Tripwire:

10-22-2008 08:58:04 UTC

“If you do, instead of dealing Damage you may remove any one Item from the damaged Clansmen…”
But you aren’t dealing Damage, so the other guy isn’t a “damaged Clansmen”.

Kevan:

10-22-2008 09:11:14 UTC

against Seems unhelpful to propose combat mechanic items, when combat isn’t yet defined. (And if the Amok Time system were reproposed, it would not work with the “instead of dealing damage, you may” of Scissors.)

Oze:

10-22-2008 12:08:37 UTC

imperial

Rodney:

10-22-2008 12:27:48 UTC

against What Kevan said. Mechanics first.

spikebrennan:

10-22-2008 12:54:22 UTC

against

Hello Sailor:

10-22-2008 14:01:44 UTC

against

Yoda:

10-22-2008 14:13:31 UTC

imperial

Rodlen:

10-22-2008 15:02:00 UTC

against

Xaxyx:

10-22-2008 15:59:36 UTC

against

Clucky:

10-22-2008 18:46:06 UTC

against If you are going to use RPS, make it work like RPS

Dustin:

10-22-2008 21:47:21 UTC

imperial

Yoda:

10-22-2008 22:44:17 UTC

against COV