Saturday, April 03, 2010

Proposal: The map is more or less fixed…

Self-killed. -Purplebeard

Adminned at 04 Apr 2010 12:50:48 UTC

In the Rule titled “Settlement” (if it exists) replace “The map of the Settlement is located here.” with:

“The map of the Settlement is located here. This wiki page may only be changed by a Proposal, a Call for Judgment or in accordance to the Ruleset.

If this page has been edited neither by a Proposal or Call for Judgment nor in accordance to the Ruleset, these changes should be reverted.

We could simply change the map to everything we want to, couldn’t we?

Comments

Hyronious:

04-03-2010 23:56:10 UTC

for Not that anyone would try…better safe than sorry. And now you’ve mentioned it, we kind of have to enact this rule.

Ienpw III:

04-04-2010 00:09:35 UTC

against Unnecessary: Rule 1.1 reads “The Ruleset and Gamestate can only be altered in manners specified by the Ruleset.

SeerPenguin:

04-04-2010 01:42:25 UTC

The question I have is, is that page considered as part of the “gamestate” as said in Rule 1.1?

But, either way, this is the wrong way to go about it, it’s quite obvious that moving is a large part of this game, and being forced to make a proposal to move would stall it quite badly.  against

Put:

04-04-2010 02:00:26 UTC

against Per Ienpw III, as soon as the mountain passes, the settlement becomes a game document and can only be changed according to the rules.

Tiberias:

04-04-2010 02:05:32 UTC

against (Not valid until I’m unidled)

Per Ienpw.

SeerPenguin: this would allow changes “in accordance to the Ruleset”, so I don’t think we’d have that problem.

Darknight:

04-04-2010 02:19:50 UTC

imperial

Kevan:

04-04-2010 09:50:09 UTC

against Although I don’t think the map becomes gamestate unless “I Never Met A Rogue I Didn’t Like” passes - gamestate is “any information which the Ruleset regulates the alteration of”, and the rule created by “The Mountain” only regulates the alteration of the GNDT Location field, it doesn’t regulate the alteration of the map.

We just need to say that the entire wiki page is gamestate.

Keba:

04-04-2010 12:47:42 UTC

S/K against per the comments above