Monday, February 01, 2010

Proposal: We’ve been here long enough that I know where the stairs are.

Vetoed and failed by Kevan - it looked like it had the power to pretty much remove the “murder” element of the game.

Adminned at 03 Feb 2010 16:43:08 UTC

Reword the text “As above, except this action may only be taken by the Detectives, the Murderers and the Servants, who all have a better knowledge of Cartlesham Manor” in the rules to “As above, except this action may be taken only once in a single dark list, except by the Detectives, the Murderers and the Servants, who all have a better knowledge of Cartlesham Manor. By these people it may be taken several times in a single list.”

posted by Ienpw III at 01 Feb 2010 14:59:07 UTC Comments (22)

Comments

Klisz:

02-01-2010 15:46:47 UTC

for

Put:

02-01-2010 15:53:03 UTC

for

Roujo:

02-01-2010 17:11:27 UTC

for

tecslicer:

02-01-2010 18:46:14 UTC

for

digibomber:

02-01-2010 18:47:39 UTC

for

Anonyman:

02-01-2010 19:47:17 UTC

for

Ornithopter:

02-01-2010 19:49:34 UTC

for

Keba:

02-01-2010 22:11:06 UTC

for

spikebrennan:

02-02-2010 00:53:53 UTC

imperial

Wakukee:

02-02-2010 01:49:39 UTC

against

Thrawn:

02-02-2010 02:15:23 UTC

for

There:

02-02-2010 04:08:28 UTC

for

Darknight:

02-02-2010 05:37:53 UTC

imperial

Rodlen:

02-02-2010 06:02:43 UTC

imperial

Kevan:

02-02-2010 10:02:03 UTC

against It’s already easy enough to turn the lights on, we don’t need everyone to be able to do it.

Oze:

02-02-2010 16:24:54 UTC

against

Ienpw III:

02-02-2010 16:35:19 UTC

It makes no thematic sense anymore…

TrumanCapote:

02-02-2010 19:15:21 UTC

against  against  against

Uvthenfuv:

02-02-2010 20:25:37 UTC

for

Excalabur:

02-03-2010 11:32:04 UTC

imperial

Roujo:

02-03-2010 12:53:48 UTC

against CoV per Kevan: It’s true that too many people with access to the fusebox will lead to very short “the lights are out” moments…

Kevan:

02-03-2010 16:42:10 UTC

veto Hesitant pro-murderer veto on this one (as obviously the murderers won’t want to argue too strenuously against it). Giving every single player the power to fix the fusebox will make it very hard for a murderer to get their Dark List processed, with the current mechanic of a “fix fusebox” action negating all other pending Dark Lists. It’s trivial for every player to submit a dark list of “Move to Basement, Fix Fusebox” on the grounds that only the first will get processed, and the others won’t even have to walk back upstairs.