I’ve made some comments over on my new blog.

In summary, I think that these ideas are broken, and need work.

>Secondly, with things the way they are, and if we say going through a Zone claims it, then people could take large swathes of land and crowd out everyone else. (Sure the respawn and strength mechanics kind of solve that, but still.) I suggest that instead, Tribes moving through occupied Zones can occupy those Zones, but otherwise only occupy the Zone their Convoy becomes inactive in.

But it can be easily /re/claimed by someone else, as long as they get support. I’m expecting land to be changing hands often with this mechanic.

Also, I was thinking that intentionally getting your land wiped out by someone else in order to snag a choice piece of land could be a bit of a gambit, but I’m open to other suggestions.

I got around to putting a wiki essay up about why I think “protosals” aren’t great. You have two slots, you can make this a proposal.

I think there’s still a place for them, and I think a complex rule like this which hasn’t yet been formally drafted is suited to protosal format.

Though you’re right that they don’t always get much attention.