Friday, October 21, 2011

Proposal: A follow-up to a follow-up to Factions

Failed by CfJ: Consensus Gamestate—Chronos Phaenon

Adminned at 23 Oct 2011 05:06:21 UTC

If the Proposal titled “This time it is a Proposal” failed, this Proposal does nothing.
Create a new sub-rule of Leaders “Rank hath its privilege” with the text:

The Leader of a Faction may veto the proposals of any Member of their Faction.
If a player votes imperial it will be counted the same as their Faction’s Leader’s vote.
The Leader of a Faction may not achieve Victory.

Per Amnistar.

This rule discourages everyone from simply spawning their own factions since then they can’t win the dynasty, as well as granting powers to leaders of the factions.

Comments

Klisz:

10-21-2011 23:38:53 UTC

for

southpointingchariot:

10-21-2011 23:40:28 UTC

against

Me and Amnistar actually found a couple bugs - I’m going to have another version ready in a couple minutes.
Under the current wording, it could be interpreted as meaning that a deferential vote would count twice, once following the Faction Leader, and once following the Emperor.
Also, it does not adress what happens if the Faction Leader votes deferential, and how votes of people that leave factions after voting works.

scshunt:

10-22-2011 00:15:59 UTC

against

Ienpw III:

10-22-2011 00:36:58 UTC

against per SPC

southpointingchariot:

10-22-2011 00:45:07 UTC

Feel free to propose the update version lenpw

Pavitra:

10-22-2011 01:07:40 UTC

against SK and I’m out of proposals.

Spitemaster:

10-22-2011 04:45:19 UTC

against