Wednesday, May 05, 2010

Proposal: A Singular Case

Enacted 17-1 (2 DEFs taking Ienpw III’s vote). Ienpw.

(Actually 15-3. You voted AGAINST, Ienpw.)

Adminned at 07 May 2010 01:07:54 UTC

In Rule 1.1, replace “including replacing Spivak pronouns with the singular “they”” with:-

including replacing Spivak and gender-specific pronouns with the singular “they”

If we’re autofixing Spivak pronouns, maybe we should autofix gender-specific pronouns as well - the current ruleset uses a mix of “he” and “they”.

Comments

muiro:

05-05-2010 14:35:20 UTC

imperial

spikebrennan:

05-05-2010 14:43:05 UTC

for

lordcooper:

05-05-2010 14:51:04 UTC

for

flurie:

05-05-2010 14:54:28 UTC

for

Keba:

05-05-2010 14:57:11 UTC

for

Klisz:

05-05-2010 15:36:14 UTC

for  Personally I’d prefer if we just used Spivak, but as long as we’re consistent I don’t care.

(Though, note, if we’re talking about two people, having the same pronoun for both gets confusing. This is why RPG books often use differently-gendered pronouns for players and the GM.)

Josh: Observer he/they

05-05-2010 15:36:32 UTC

for

spikebrennan:

05-05-2010 15:38:29 UTC

If one’s pronouns are confusing, he made a mistake and you need to rewrite the sentence.

Klisz:

05-05-2010 15:48:06 UTC

@spikebrennan: No, I’m saying that it’s confusing for them all to be the same, not for them all to be different.

spikebrennan:

05-05-2010 16:25:30 UTC

darth- I was joking.

redtara: they/them

05-05-2010 20:24:01 UTC

against

Jumblin McGrumblin:

05-05-2010 20:49:18 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

06-05-2010 00:15:44 UTC

for

Klisz:

06-05-2010 00:42:25 UTC

@spikebrennan: Ah, okay, I thought you were genuinely trying to convince me.

redtara: they/them

06-05-2010 01:47:03 UTC

“If one’s pronouns are confusing, he...”

dbdougla:

06-05-2010 05:20:27 UTC

for

Galdyn:

06-05-2010 06:17:04 UTC

for

scshunt:

06-05-2010 08:01:32 UTC

imperial

Qwazukee:

06-05-2010 08:38:36 UTC

for

Put:

06-05-2010 10:02:07 UTC

for

Igthorn:

06-05-2010 19:10:43 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

06-05-2010 21:20:20 UTC

for