Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Proposal: A trivial one

Vetoed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 18 May 2011 05:47:15 UTC

Through all the Dynastic Rules, replace the word Sun with the word Water.

I wanted to make a smart proposal but due to lack of ideas I decided to post this.

Comments

Kevan:

05-17-2011 20:14:13 UTC

for Good call, makes a lot more sense.

Yoda:

05-17-2011 20:15:15 UTC

for

SingularByte:

05-17-2011 20:22:08 UTC

for

Bucky:

05-17-2011 20:22:57 UTC

for

Roujo:

05-17-2011 20:23:12 UTC

for =)

scshunt:

05-17-2011 20:25:11 UTC

for

Ienpw III:

05-17-2011 20:27:03 UTC

against Sun sounds cooler, like we are playing with liquid Light.

Keba:

05-17-2011 20:31:07 UTC

From a biologic point of view, plants to not need sun to grow (for an example: there is no sun under the ground), but water is necessary. ;)

But I give a damn on the biology. Sun‘s just cooler, and we could plant sunflowers later. Does anyone knows waterflowers?

against

Winner:

05-17-2011 20:32:27 UTC

for

Yoda:

05-17-2011 20:32:58 UTC

against CoV.  I forgot about sunflowers.  They’re in the wiki page with the types of seeds.

Hix:

05-17-2011 20:33:13 UTC

against I like Sun better.  Water should be plentiful (not necessarily unlimited, but I don’t like it being the main “currency”)

Hix:

05-17-2011 20:35:52 UTC

(Double post, sorry)  Proposal posters who take a long time to type up a proposal in Expression Engine should make sure that the timestamp is accurate before posting (I should know, I’m really slow).  This proposal retroactively neuters one that was posted to the blog first!

Roujo:

05-17-2011 20:37:50 UTC

CoV Let’s play Plants vs Zombies! =D

Ely:

05-17-2011 20:49:23 UTC

[hix] sorry, I didn’t think about it.

Trust me, when farming there’s plentyful of sun and always too little water.
At least where I live ;P

Yoda:

05-17-2011 21:43:05 UTC

veto To make way for Plant vs. Zombies.

Kevan:

05-17-2011 23:06:38 UTC

I know this proposal predates you announcing the real theme, but vetoing a proposal that has a majority, because it doesn’t match a game that not everyone here has played, isn’t a good route to go down for a fun game of Nomic.

Roujo:

05-18-2011 00:22:23 UTC

Forgot to actually vote in my CoV, so for what it’s worth… against.

Yoda:

05-18-2011 04:07:54 UTC

@Kevan: The fact that this rule would also break the proposal directly after it and being that this proposal is admittedly trivial, I didn’t think it would be much of any issue.

Josh:

05-18-2011 06:29:29 UTC

Yeah I think this was a bad veto. Not a huge deal perhaps but still.