Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Proposal: Admin Edits, Darth Edition

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 18 Mar 2009 08:12:21 UTC

Make a new rule, “Admin Cuts”:

Once per Act an Admin, called the Editor, may cut one scene from the Act before it is fiinished.

Redoing the other proposal.

posted by Klisz at 17 Mar 2009 16:23:01 UTC Comments (15)

Comments

Influenza:

17-03-2009 16:28:14 UTC

imperial But who decides which admin is the editor? and will the editor be a different admin?

Influenza:

17-03-2009 16:29:31 UTC

uhh I mean will the editor change between acts :d sorry for the double comment ^^

Kevan: he/him

17-03-2009 16:30:10 UTC

I guess the first admin to grab the scissors gets it.

against Seems a bit unfair on non-admins. Giving a specific player the job of “Editor” might be interesting, though.

Klisz:

17-03-2009 16:30:35 UTC

The Editor is whoever goes and decides to do it first… when a rule says “a player, called X, can do this”, then X is whoever does that first.

Klisz:

17-03-2009 16:31:08 UTC

Posted at the same time as Influenza and Kevan.

Klisz:

17-03-2009 16:32:38 UTC

imperial  author def; I’m only doing this to help Gill Smoke anyway.

Rodlen:

17-03-2009 17:04:47 UTC

against Hell no.

ais523:

17-03-2009 18:56:29 UTC

against Cutting a scene should do something, I think.

Kevan: he/him

17-03-2009 19:13:29 UTC

It does; the scene’s writer loses points, and the scene doesn’t make it to the wiki archive.

Devenger:

17-03-2009 19:18:50 UTC

against I’m against admins having unnecessary advantages. As said above, giving the title to a willing and active player through a proposed rule would be good.

Jeid:

17-03-2009 19:37:17 UTC

imperial

Qwazukee:

17-03-2009 19:38:40 UTC

against Although there’s nothing wrong with the editor idea.

Darknight: he/him

17-03-2009 20:06:40 UTC

against

gill_smoke:

17-03-2009 22:32:06 UTC

for It’s my Idea, I’m not an admin but I’d like the thought of Editor(s) trying to keep the ‘film’ on track.

Klisz:

17-03-2009 22:59:08 UTC

Gill, your vote does nothing. I voted def, Devenger voted against, therefore this is self-killed.