Monday, December 05, 2005

Proposal: Advice

Reached quorum 10-3 (With Angel’s vote being FOR (because of the tie between Angel supporters), Devil’s AGAINST, and Fred’s DEFERENTIAL counting as FOR)

Adminned at 05 Dec 2005 09:59:36 UTC

Append the following text to the rule entitled “Whispers”:

Occasionally, a Voice may change the Whispering value of the Voice to whom e is currently Whispering to any legal value.

If Angel is Whispering to a Voice, that Voice may only cast FOR votes.
If Devil is Whispering to a Voice, that Voice may only cast AGAINST votes.
If Fred is Whispering to a Voice, that Voice may only cast DEFERENTIAL votes.

posted by Cayvie at 05 Dec 2005 03:36:13 UTC Comments (14)

Comments

Cayvie:

05-12-2005 03:51:42 UTC

By the way, a logical corollary of this is that if any two of these guys are whispering to a Voice, that Voice cannot vote.

Angry Grasshopper:

05-12-2005 04:02:09 UTC

Oh. My.

Excalabur:

05-12-2005 04:30:42 UTC

yes AG?
for

Hix:

05-12-2005 04:31:32 UTC

for

Quazie:

05-12-2005 04:47:24 UTC

for
but i think that certain combos should involve dice rolls

The Lone Amigo:

05-12-2005 06:07:43 UTC

for

Moonwryn:

05-12-2005 09:00:25 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

05-12-2005 09:22:10 UTC

for

ChronosPhaenon:

05-12-2005 12:25:51 UTC

imperial

Rodney:

05-12-2005 14:44:26 UTC

for Insanity!

smith:

05-12-2005 16:04:21 UTC

against Won’t this allow the Angelic voices to force victory awfully quickly… it seems dangerous

Hix:

05-12-2005 16:07:43 UTC

The Voting restriction only applies if Angel emself is the one whispering.

Hix:

05-12-2005 17:22:12 UTC

against CoV.  There was dispute last dynasty about whether “votes” on a Call for Judgement or on a Declaration of Victory count as actual votes.  I don’t think anyone should be prevented from voting however e wants on a CfJ.

TrumanCapote:

05-12-2005 17:59:35 UTC

against