Saturday, June 03, 2023

Proposal: Better Than Life

failed 1-5 with 1 unresolved DEF by chiiika.

Adminned at 05 Jun 2023 18:38:36 UTC

In “Reality Recurse”, replace “If a Mindjacker has a Suspicion of more than or equal to 5, as a Action said Mindjacker can Descend.” (if that text exists there) with:-

A Mindjacker may Descend at any time.

May as well allow players to plug straight in to the next-lower-level simulation if they want to live there, rather than having to goad the Reality Enforcers into putting them there as a punishment, each time.

Comments

summai:

03-06-2023 19:01:34 UTC

This does fit thematically, but it might make the game more interesting if we’re not allowed to Descend at will so most likely a no from me.

JonathanDark: he/him

03-06-2023 21:36:14 UTC

If “One Way Out” passes, there may be reasons to slow down Descending at will.

Chiiika: she/her

04-06-2023 07:41:50 UTC

imperial

Josh: he/they

04-06-2023 10:52:16 UTC

imperial

Kevan: City he/him

04-06-2023 14:20:18 UTC

There’s already a cost to Descending in the fact that you’re giving up the opportunities afforded by higher levels, and having to go through the effort of Ascending again if you want to get back.

This is just a flip from the (at time of writing) “descending is impossible” to “descending is easy”. I generally think a rule that’s interesting but thematically unintuitive is harder to build on than one that’s simple but has a clearer narrative.

summai:

04-06-2023 17:07:12 UTC

  against It is not necessary that being at a higher Level gives more opportunities as can be seen by some of the rules in One Way Out. In fact there might be more restrictions at higher Levels.

lemon: she/her

04-06-2023 18:24:43 UTC

against

Bucky:

04-06-2023 20:32:21 UTC

against

Raven1207: he/they

05-06-2023 02:04:56 UTC

against