Sunday, March 18, 2012

Proposal: Blogia Reform

Reached quorum, final vote 9-3 -Klisz

Adminned at 19 Mar 2012 09:56:32 UTC

Change, in the rule “Cycle Resolution”, the text:

When an Institution is resolved, if any Player Directed any Marines at that Institution that Cycle, then the Player who directed the most Marines at the Institution that Cycle Influences that Institution. Otherwise, the Player that Directed the most Credits at that Institution that Cycle Influences it. If no player directed any Marines or Credits at that Institution that Cycle, or there is a tie, no player Influences it.

to:

When an Institution is resolved, it is Influenced by the Player who Directed more Marines to that Institution than any other Player, provided there is one. If there is none, if one of the Players who Directed the most Marines to that Institution has Directed more Credits than any of the other Players who Directed the most Marines to that Institution, then that Player influences the Institution. If there is none, no Player Influences that Institution.

In the same rule, change the text:

Each player earns 1 Credit for each Institution which they Directed Resources at but did not Influence that Cycle. Additionally, each player who has no Credits and Directed no Resources that Cycle gains 1 Credit.

to:

Each Player earns 1 Credit for each Institution which they Directed at least one Marine or Credit to but did not Influence that Cycle. Additionally, each player who has no Credits and Directed 0 Credits and 0 Marines that Cycle gains 1 Credit.

Adds some useful clarification.

Comments

Patrick:

18-03-2012 02:58:31 UTC

for

omd:

18-03-2012 03:19:32 UTC

against I don’t like the substantive change or the new wording. :)

Doctor29:

18-03-2012 03:20:44 UTC

for

Bucky:

18-03-2012 06:39:15 UTC

imperial

Josh: Observer he/they

18-03-2012 08:02:19 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

18-03-2012 21:45:15 UTC

imperial

ChronosPhaenon:

18-03-2012 23:53:51 UTC

for

scshunt:

19-03-2012 00:33:43 UTC

against agree with omd.

Soviet Brendon:

19-03-2012 04:18:18 UTC

against

Cpt_Koen:

19-03-2012 16:15:14 UTC

I don’t think changing “Additionally, each player who has no Credits and Directed no Resources that Cycle gains 1 Credit.” is needed.
for for the first part, though

(the main difference between the two wordings is that with the new, you can direct both Marines and Credits to the same institution)

southpointingchariot:

19-03-2012 16:16:41 UTC

@Koen, that part was from Bucky’s proposal which has already passed.

Klisz:

19-03-2012 16:54:13 UTC

for