Wednesday, February 02, 2011

Call for Judgment: Bread and Games

Passes at 10-0. -Purplebeard

Adminned at 04 Feb 2011 01:55:34 UTC

Winner took an action yesterday evening which I believe to be illegal. They dropped a crumb to give seven Ants 5 food each. I believe that this action does not conform to any reasonable interpretation of “distribute up to 5 food among all Ants in their location” in “Dropping and Using”. The wording makes it clear that no more than 5 food may be produced by a single crumb. Moreover, since this action caused several Ants’ food statistics to hold an illegal value, it couldn’t have been taken per the fourth bullet point of “Numbers and Variables”.

Therefore, revert this action.

We might as well remove the ambiguity in “Numbers and Variables” while we’re at it, so change

b) the action would change one of those values to an illegal value.

to

b) the action would change one or more of those values to an illegal value.

Comments

Ely:

02-02-2011 08:41:46 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

02-02-2011 09:22:20 UTC

for

Subrincinator:

02-02-2011 12:33:13 UTC

imperial

Chivalrybean:

02-02-2011 14:16:35 UTC

for

Klisz:

02-02-2011 15:50:32 UTC

for

Winner:

02-02-2011 16:27:39 UTC

imperial sorry.

William:

02-02-2011 20:42:58 UTC

for

Roujo: he/him

02-02-2011 22:07:31 UTC

for Good idea. =)

Blacky:

02-02-2011 22:58:28 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

02-02-2011 23:44:35 UTC

for

Bucky:

02-02-2011 23:58:57 UTC

for