Thursday, October 20, 2011

Call for Judgment: Call for Judgment: Categorical imperative, redux

failed by CfJ “http://blognomic.com/archive/compromise_mark_4_again” -Bucky
unfailed by coppro - the enactment was illegal

CfJ is illegal because it does not “describe the issue” per Rule 1.7. -Ornithopter

Adminned at 22 Oct 2011 14:20:00 UTC

(Done correctly this time, I hope.  My bad for not reading the FAQs first.)

Amend Rule 3.1 by inserting this text immediately after the definition of “Can”:

Category
  A type of Official Post defined or mentioned by the rules as being a “category”.

and by replacing the definition of “Story Post” with this text:

A Story Post is an Official Post that does not belong to any category.

Amend Rule 3.2 by replacing all text in the first paragraph after “Posts following the format specified by a rule are considered official posts.” with this text:

An official post cannot simultaneously belong to more than one category unless otherwise specified by dynastic rules.

 

posted by Murphy at 20 Oct 2011 20:18:59 UTC Comments (20)

Comments

Klisz:

20-10-2011 20:43:57 UTC

for

Pavitra:

20-10-2011 21:07:07 UTC

for

Murphy:

20-10-2011 23:44:48 UTC

for

Sorry about the duplicate prefix. Again, should have read the FAQs more closely first. (FYI preview didn’t show the problem.)

Bucky:

20-10-2011 23:48:40 UTC

against  because I don’t like the way Category is defined; it might easily break dynastic rules by accident.

redtara: they/them

21-10-2011 00:00:23 UTC

against per Bucky.

Shadowclaw:

21-10-2011 00:11:10 UTC

against

Ornithopter:

21-10-2011 00:58:04 UTC

against per Bucky

Pavitra:

21-10-2011 01:28:46 UTC

Yeah, good point. against

Brendan: he/him

21-10-2011 03:15:07 UTC

against

Murphy:

21-10-2011 03:22:55 UTC

Suggested patch:

Category
  A type of Official Post defined or mentioned by the rules as being a “category”.

Exclusive category
  A category defined or mentioned by the core rules, or defined or mentioned by the rules as being an “exclusive category”.

An official post cannot simultaneously belong to more than one exclusive category unless otherwise specified by dynastic rules.

scshunt:

21-10-2011 06:56:09 UTC

for

I’d rather break the dynastic rules than leave the core damaged

Kevan: he/him

21-10-2011 10:54:39 UTC

against

Wooble:

21-10-2011 11:22:20 UTC

for

Prince Anduril:

21-10-2011 12:08:35 UTC

for

Rodney:

21-10-2011 13:43:54 UTC

against

Prince Anduril:

21-10-2011 13:44:21 UTC

against CoV - See my/coppro’s alternative.

ChronosPhaenon:

21-10-2011 14:15:10 UTC

against

southpointingchariot:

22-10-2011 04:48:16 UTC

against

Josh: Observer he/they

22-10-2011 10:30:53 UTC

against

Brendan: he/him

22-10-2011 18:17:57 UTC

4-12 by my count.