Good point.

If a prisoner were seen on the streets at night I’d be very, very worried.

You’re just changing “N”, you aren’t changing the list of villagers selected from (which is just “randomly selected villagers”, and includes the dead).

Hahahaha.

What? It says living villagers?

The only thing this should change is you can’t see a prisioner out on the streets at night.

The rule still says to select “N other randomly selected villagers”, it needs to say “randomly selected living villagers (excluding the Prisoner)”.

You’re just changing the definition of N, you aren’t changing the pool of villagers from which N villagers are chosen.

Ah… well, I didn’t write that part… I just added the bit about prisioners.

Issues

I used the exact wording from the rules set and only added the words “and anyone with an occupation of Prisoner.”

Looks like it was broken to begin with, but that’s not a reason to fail this proposal.

It wasn’t broken to begin with—the count was supposed to exclude the Werewolf, presumably in case the game gets down to a very small number of living Villagers.  Anything about Prisoners should be in a separate clause.

It was arguably broken that the Night Watchman could sometimes see dead villagers on the streets.

The current wording just decreases “N” without doing anything thematically logical, so I think we can live without it and wait for the next fix.

CoV

CoV

Since it’s only blocking the queue now.