Sunday, March 16, 2008

Proposal: Captain’s Challenge (On Purpose Now)

timed out, final vote 1-4—Yoda

Adminned at 17 Mar 2008 18:24:45 UTC

Since sometimes your army is small
(Really barely an army at all),
Let’s amend rule “Battles”
To protect the cattle
Well all pets, be they short or tall:

If an attacked captain favours eir army,
To save their poor bottoms from harm, e
May replace dice results
With a swordfight of insults,
And resolve the battle with charm, see?

Since this is a one-on-one fight,
Rather than a battle of might,
No army’s reduc-ed
(No pet loses its head)
Still, the loser is a “Bitter” sight.

I am giving up on trying to force complete rules into limericks, so the above is just for flavour. Text to be added to “Battles” follows:

Within 24 hours of the blogpost stating the Attack, the Attacked Captain may challenge the Attacking Captain to an Insult Swordfight as in the rule “Insult Swordfighting” (so long as such a Swordfight is legal by the terms of the rule). If the challenge is accepted, the Swordfight shall determine the outcome of the battle (no DICE are rolled). If the Attacking Captain wins the Insult Swordfight, e takes the gold from the Swordfight as well as the gold from a succesful Attack. If the Attacked Captain wins the Insult Swordfight, e takes the gold from the Swordfight, but the Attacking Captain’s Army is not reduced.

If the majority of the comments for this proposal that have active FOR votes contain the words “Subrules are more better”, make the text in the blockquote a subrule of “Battles” called “Captain’s Challenge”.

Comments

Yoda:

16-03-2008 01:12:17 UTC

against
This makes it sound like this is the only way two captains can participate in an insult swordfight.

Also, what happens if the attacking captain declines or does not respond to the challenge?

Dustin:

16-03-2008 02:52:17 UTC

against

Lugosh:

16-03-2008 10:11:16 UTC

How does this make it sound like this is the only way two captains could participate in a swordfight? Insult Swordfighting is already its own rule, specifying when captains may participate in an insult swordfight.

If the Attacking Captain declines, then the battle will go through as normal, with dice rolls.

If the Attacking Captain does not respond to the challenge, it shall be treated as if e declined.

Jack:

16-03-2008 14:00:58 UTC

against

Darknight: he/him

16-03-2008 18:51:55 UTC

against