Thursday, September 14, 2006

Proposal: Changing Harmony

2-5, timed out. -Elias IX

Adminned at 17 Sep 2006 14:09:16 UTC

Add the following to the “Harmony” part of rule “Style” as follows:

If there are more than four Musicians in a row with Harmony Consonant,  then the Harmony of the two end Musicians switches from Consonant to Dissonant. If there are more than four Musicians in a row with Harmony Dissonant, then the Harmony of the two end Musicians switches from Dissonant to Consonant.

Comments

Thrawn:

09-15-2006 02:15:05 UTC

for

Elias IX:

09-15-2006 02:18:13 UTC

against No… not too much?

Hix:

09-15-2006 03:01:44 UTC

against Interesting, but I’d prefer not.

Thelonious:

09-15-2006 08:37:03 UTC

against

Thelonious:

09-15-2006 08:38:05 UTC

This also raises an interesting question.  When two or more rules for adjusting style values have their conditions met simultaneously, which one should be applied first?

ChronosPhaenon:

09-15-2006 10:59:11 UTC

They are all applied simultaneously. If all of them try to change the value in the same way, the value changes. If not, the value remains unchanged. It’s somewhere in the Harmony rule.

imperial

gazebo_dude:

09-16-2006 04:30:01 UTC

imperial