Monday, September 13, 2010

Proposal: Chorus of Disapproval

Timed out and enacted, 6-2. Josh

Adminned at 15 Sep 2010 07:38:19 UTC

Add a subrule to Rule 2.2, and call it “We Give Up”:-

Any Befuddled may reply to a Competition by posting a comment with a single AGAINST vote. This is known as a Disapproval, and for the purposes of Rule 2.2, this does not count as having “posted in the post”. If a Competition blog post has Disapprovals from a number of Befuddleds equal to or greater than Quorum, it no longer counts as a Competition.

posted by Kevan at 13 Sep 2010 14:03:18 UTC Comments (11)

Comments

Bucky:

13-09-2010 14:36:03 UTC

against

Josh: he/they

13-09-2010 14:55:53 UTC

for

flurie:

13-09-2010 15:03:05 UTC

I like the idea, but I’m not sure I like this implementation of it. Abstaining for now.

ais523: Custodian

13-09-2010 15:17:59 UTC

for

Bucky:

13-09-2010 16:02:57 UTC

I think this is a bad idea because it lets the losers of a large competition cooperate to avoid the consequences.

ais523: Custodian

13-09-2010 16:05:42 UTC

It’s unlikely that they’d manage to get a quorum together before the consequences could happen, isn’t it?

lilomar:

13-09-2010 16:54:09 UTC

imperial , but with reservations, per Bucky.

Bucky:

13-09-2010 17:11:31 UTC

I further add that if some competition really needs to be killed, we can always do it by proposal or CfJ.

Maximus:

13-09-2010 19:00:51 UTC

I agree with bucky. against

Darknight: he/him

14-09-2010 00:05:06 UTC

against

Klisz:

14-09-2010 17:43:21 UTC

for