Call for Judgment: Chronology II
Timed out and failed, 5-3. Josh
Adminned at 25 Feb 2007 15:31:17 UTC
Description of problem: some Actors have added roles that are against the current rules.
Proposed solution:
Remove all roles from Actors’ filmographies that violate either of the clauses:
* A role of “Nth Minor Character†may only be added if the Actor has been an Extra in three earlier films.
* A named role may only be added if the Actor has been an Nth Minor Character in three earlier films.
If “Making Movies… BACK IN TIME” has passed, however, do not remove any roles that were added after it was enacted.
Actors whose roles have been removed to may add one valid role (per deleted role) as if it had been added at the same time as the deleted role (including the state of the rules). If any Actor adds a role per the regular rules of the game, e forfeits eir right to replace any remaining deleted role.
Hix:
honest “mistakes” due to use of ambiguous “earlier films”. I won’t always condone misinterpretations of ambiguous rules, but this one is harmless, and I think we’re best off letting the “mistakes” stand, passing “Making Movies… BACK IN TIME”, and getting along with the game.