Saturday, January 14, 2017

Proposal: Clean Slate

Reached quorum 5 votes to 1. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 16 Jan 2017 09:19:38 UTC

Set the Remedies carried by Cuddlebeam to be three Well Waters.

Since Cuddlebeam’s inventory hasn’t been accurately tracked in the GNDT and we don’t know what this Villager is actually carrying.

Comments

pokes:

01-14-2017 12:03:25 UTC

Note: I’d vote against this but for a proposal that reverted their inventory to 593 waters, which as far as I can tell was legalized in that instance by their CfJ.

Kevan:

01-14-2017 12:10:20 UTC

Note: Have now changed this from “remove all Remedies” to “three Well Waters” if that seems fairer. The enactment of May Day would make it illegal to carry 593 waters, and would automatically reduce it to 3.

Cuddlebeam’s CfJ doesn’t appear to give a specific number (“A hundred? Thousands? I dunno”), it just asks for the carrying of them to be recognised as legal.

pokes:

01-14-2017 12:15:58 UTC

for

Cuddlebeam:

01-14-2017 12:16:19 UTC

This is just a smaller version of a proposal which already exists, called “May Day”, because “May Day” says “If any Villager has more than three Remedies, remove all but three of those Remedies.”, which accomplishes the same result.

against Redundant proposal.

Viv:

01-14-2017 12:23:20 UTC

I would like to see the infinite well water situation cleared up, this seems very reasonable. Putting an unspecified number as a placeholder for however many units someone wants to use later while claiming that technically it could have been any number cannot be a legal move, and although that went through the gamestat should be corrected now.
for

Kevan:

01-14-2017 12:23:56 UTC

Your inventory could also be fewer than three Water, or possibly (from your unexplained “Taking a Random plant DICE5” actions in the GNDT an hour ago) a plant.

Matt:

01-14-2017 22:36:24 UTC

for

quirck:

01-15-2017 11:05:58 UTC

for