Wednesday, October 14, 2015

Proposal: Cleansing

Passes 5-0. Enacted by Brendan.

Adminned at 15 Oct 2015 18:51:55 UTC

Add the following sentence to the last paragraph of the rule Conclaves:

After a Scrutineer announces in this way that dark smoke has been released, all Scrutineers may, within the following 48 hours, select a Cardinal and remove that Cardinal’s Vice.

 

Comments

Kevan:

10-14-2015 09:00:27 UTC

Having to unanimously agree as a group to de-Vice a single Cardinal, or picking and de-Vicing one each?

Elias IX:

10-14-2015 15:21:07 UTC

Each Cardinal selects one - I suppose I can reword “all Scrutineers” to “each Scrutineer” in a future proposal. Alternatively, is it okay if we as a group come to a consensus informally that the current wording means each Scrutineer chooses one?

ayesdeeef:

10-14-2015 21:23:36 UTC

That’s what I thought when I first read it before Kevan’s comment Elias, but now Kevan makes a fair point.

Although I initially read it like Elias, I’m not a bit confused but yeah I can agree informally with Elias. for

Brendan:

10-14-2015 22:19:05 UTC

for Blognomic needs more exploits.

delcooper11:

10-15-2015 05:47:21 UTC

for

Kevan:

10-15-2015 08:12:39 UTC

for

Roberto:

10-15-2015 18:19:53 UTC

for