Tuesday, June 15, 2021

Call for Judgment: Closure

As CfJ: Closurer was enacted, this CfJ no longer changes the gamestate or ruleset, so can be failed.

Adminned at 17 Jun 2021 09:29:53 UTC

Uphold the completion of the following Atomic Actions at the detailed times:

The Entering the Crypt action culminating in the story post Richardo’s First Expedition, completed at 11 June 2021, 19:32:00 UTC
The Entering the Crypt action culminating in the story post Richardo’s Second Expedition, completed at 13 June 2021, 19:48:00 UTC
The Entering the Crypt action culminating in the story post Richardo’s Third Expedition, completed at 15 June 2021, 21:40:00 UTC

“If one or more steps of an Atomic Action were done incorrectly, the Vampire Lord must redo the Atomic Action”. Unfortunately, all three of these AAs were done incorrectly, as the summary post is supposed to “summarising [the] Enter the Crypt action, including detailing any variables changed”. None of them detail the changes made to Richardo’s Energy so none of them have been legally completed.

Tomorrow I’m going to put up a proposal fixing a number of issues with the AA, this one included, but I did just want to make sure that the gamestate wasn’t going to slip into the sea in the meanwhile.

posted by Josh at 15 Jun 2021 22:45:00 UTC Comments (11)

Comments

Clucky: he/him

15-06-2021 23:01:41 UTC

for

Clucky: he/him

15-06-2021 23:02:08 UTC

wait crap, “The Entering the Crypt action culminating in the story post Richardo’s Third Expedition, completed at *13 June* 2021, 21:40:00 UTC” is wrong

ais523:

16-06-2021 00:20:09 UTC

against Wrong dates.

Josh: Observer he/they

16-06-2021 06:47:03 UTC

Oops.

But also: typo. So I’m just going to change it.

Kevan: he/him

16-06-2021 08:02:18 UTC

for Hats off to Clucky for spotting and exploiting the timing on the third.

Brendan: he/him

16-06-2021 16:27:37 UTC

for

Janet: she/her

16-06-2021 17:43:26 UTC

against

Raven1207: he/they

17-06-2021 04:15:26 UTC

against

lemon: she/her

17-06-2021 07:42:24 UTC

@kevan “spotting and exploiting”, is there some context im missing here :0? that wording makes it sound like clucky somehow gained an advantage from correcting the mistake / making a second proposal

Josh: Observer he/they

17-06-2021 08:51:04 UTC

@lemon


The third Richardo’s Journey post went up 9.02pm. Ostensibly, it closed off the atomic action.

Clucky noticed that it did not include everybody’s Puissance changes, therefore did not “detail all variable changes”, therefore did not actually close the AA.

Per the rule Atomic Actions, an Atomic Action takes place at the time that the last step completes.

Noticing that, he inscribed a sigil in the Crypt Entrance, knowing that per the rule Atomic Actions I would have to let the AA play out in exactly the same way so he would gain from it.

He then let me know that the AA wasn’t complete and that as his sigil now had to be accommodated he had to be awarded 1 extra Puissance.

All in all, a very neatly done exploit of the rules.

lemon: she/her

17-06-2021 08:57:41 UTC

ohhh, i see!!! that’s pretty neat :0