Friday, October 02, 2015

Proposal: Core Proposal: Quit while you’re ahead

Fewer than a quorum of players not voting against. Failed 1-4 by Kevan.

Adminned at 04 Oct 2015 16:59:11 UTC

Amend Idle Prisoners in the Core Rules

When a prisoner is idled by their own request, any pending proposals submitted by that prisoner shall be considered self-killed.

Comments

ais523:

10-03-2015 02:02:35 UTC

against because you don’t explain where in the rule the new text goes, or if anything that exists in the rule is being replaced. If I were trying to write your proposal directly, I’d write it along the lines of “Amend the rule ‘Idle Prisoners’ by appending the following paragraph:”

However, I’d prefer it even more if we simply added a new bullet point to “Resolution of Proposals” allowing the oldest pending proposal to be failed if the Prisoner who proposed it is idle; it’d be easier to find it in the ruleset there, and is less likely to interfere with dynastic mechanics that influence voting.

Kevan:

10-03-2015 07:38:33 UTC

against Proposals can stand alone in the absence of their proposer.

Purplebeard:

10-03-2015 08:22:58 UTC

against I agree with Kevan.

Darknight:

10-03-2015 14:50:01 UTC

against