Sunday, June 06, 2021

Proposal: Covering some bases

self killed—Clucky

Adminned at 08 Jun 2021 06:15:10 UTC

In “Ballot Submissions” after

A Ballot Submission consists of the titles of three different pieces of art from the gallery for the previous round, ranked, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd, signifying which pieces they wish to praise. The Collector encourages Brokers to take into account creativity, originality, artistic beauty and adherence to the theme when determining which pieces to praise. A ballot submission may not include the title of a pieces of art which were submitted by the Broker making the ballot submission.

add

If there are fewer than three pieces of art from the gallery for the previous round which were not submitted by the Broker sending a ballot submission, that Broker’s ballot submission may include fewer than three items. In order for it to be valid, every piece of art from the galley for the previous round which was not submitted by the Broker must be included, and they must fill the highest ranks possible (with 1st being the highest, so for example, if there were only two such pieces of art, in order for the submission to be valid they must rank one of those pieces of art 1st, and the other one 2nd, but do not need to rank anything 3rd).

Hope this doesn’t actually come up, but occurred to me that it could and would rather just cover stuff now than have to CfJ something tomorrow if it does come up.

Comments

Bucky:

06-06-2021 03:43:29 UTC

The “In order for it to be valid” sentence should have the “with fewer than three items” spelled out, lest it be interpreted as applying also to “A Ballot Submission consists of the titles of three different pieces of art…”

Kevan: HE/HIM

06-06-2021 12:35:51 UTC

against Per Bucky, and it being a rare thing that we can pause and CfJ if it actually happens.

Clucky: HE/HIM

06-06-2021 15:28:37 UTC

against not needed