Tuesday, June 19, 2018

Proposal: Discard dis Card

Reached Quorum 6 to 1. Enacted by derrick.

Adminned at 20 Jun 2018 13:08:49 UTC

create a rule named “Discarding”:

A wizard may discard a card when instructed to by a card’s effect. When a wizard discards a card, it is removed from that wizard’s hand. A wizard may not discard a card they do not have in their hand. If a card effect would require a wizard to discard a card they do not have in their hand, that effect may not be performed when the wizard plays the card. The most powerful effects in the game should require cards to be discarded as part of their effect.

 

posted by derrick at 19 Jun 2018 20:23:00 UTC Comments (8)

Comments

Axemabaro:

19-06-2018 23:59:00 UTC

“The most powerful effects in the game should require cards to be discarded as part of their effect.” Doesn’t seem like it should be rule text.

derrick: he/him

20-06-2018 01:19:04 UTC

Nope! its almost completely unenforceable.

card:

20-06-2018 01:43:48 UTC

imperial

Lulu: she/her

20-06-2018 02:50:50 UTC

for can’t wait for this to be self-killed

pokes:

20-06-2018 04:07:27 UTC

imperial

Corona:

20-06-2018 05:29:12 UTC

imperial

Brendan: he/him

20-06-2018 05:36:54 UTC

against I think this is effectively encapsulated within existing proposals.

Kevan: he/him

20-06-2018 07:48:25 UTC

imperial This does seem like overkill; I think “discarding means removing from your hand” would cover it.