Tuesday, March 16, 2021

Call for Judgment: Eleven hours is foreverrrrr

Fewer than a quorum not voting against. Failed 4-6 by Kevan.

Adminned at 17 Mar 2021 11:34:45 UTC

Upon enactment of this CfJ, any pending DoV that is Unpopular may be immediately failed.

Comments

Bucky:

16-03-2021 22:39:59 UTC

Is this supposed to amend the rules? CfJs can’t otherwise permit an illegal future action, as that goes beyond changing the gamestate.

Or maybe you just meant “fail all pending Unpopular DoVs”.

Bucky:

16-03-2021 22:44:33 UTC

against because this makes failing the DoVs optional on an individual basis. Either fail them, or don’t fail them.

Clucky: he/him

16-03-2021 22:45:11 UTC

why not just fix the rules so unpopular DoVs don’t need 12 hours to fail?

trying to remember why we included that. I’m sure after all this time we have our reasons, right?

Josh: Observer he/they

16-03-2021 22:46:35 UTC

@clucky I tend towards the belief that a CfJ shouldn’t change rules unless it’s necessary to get out of a hole; we should save the rule change for after the hiatus.

Clucky: he/him

16-03-2021 22:48:25 UTC

for

Zack: he/him

16-03-2021 22:49:35 UTC

for this is pretty straightforward

Lulu: she/her

16-03-2021 22:54:47 UTC

against still in debate

Brendan: he/him

16-03-2021 23:19:09 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

16-03-2021 23:19:39 UTC

against

[Clucky] I think the 12 hour thing is to discourage speculative DoVs that get retracted five minutes later. If they were cheap and easily taken down, it would be tempting to always throw them out just in case, whenever you half-saw a possible scam, if you weren’t expecting to win any other way over the next four days.

Darknight: he/him

16-03-2021 23:26:26 UTC

against

Raven1207: he/they

17-03-2021 03:55:41 UTC

for

Josh: Observer he/they

17-03-2021 09:41:12 UTC

against

pokes:

17-03-2021 10:45:19 UTC

against

Lulu: she/her

17-03-2021 10:53:23 UTC

Hey look, 11 hours wasn’t all of eternity!