Friday, October 21, 2011

Call for Judgment: Emergency Law

failed by CfJ “http://blognomic.com/archive/compromise_mark_4_again” -Bucky
unfailed by coppro - the enactment was illegal

CfJ is illegal because it does not “describe the issue” per Rule 1.7. -Ornithopter

Adminned at 22 Oct 2011 14:22:15 UTC

Create a core rule, Emergency Law:

Any CfJ or Proposal (referred to in this rule as “the Post” which meets the following conditions is invalid:
* The Post is or was posted between 19 OCT 2011 21:24:37 UTC and 03 NOV 2011 21:24:37 UTC.
* The Post is or was posted by a player who has, according to the rules of Agora (the nomic described at http://www.agoranomic.org/), been an active player of that nomic at any point since 19 AUG 2011 21:24:37 UTC.

Any Enacted CfJ or Proposal which meets the two conditions described above is considered to have never been valid.

Comments

redtara: they/them

21-10-2011 00:28:31 UTC

I don’t think this is too harsh. They are invading us; we must defend ourselves.

It’s not just the new Agoran players who we have to worry about, either. Coppro authored the CotC CfJ and ais is voting for it.

scshunt:

21-10-2011 00:29:56 UTC

against

zuff:

21-10-2011 00:30:23 UTC

against Creampuff.

redtara: they/them

21-10-2011 00:31:43 UTC

Obvious typographical error: there should be a closing bracket after “the Post”. That’s the only place it will go.

redtara: they/them

21-10-2011 00:34:20 UTC

Can go, I mean.

Shadowclaw:

21-10-2011 01:13:59 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

21-10-2011 01:16:50 UTC

for

Pavitra:

21-10-2011 01:26:17 UTC

against

Murphy:

21-10-2011 01:27:56 UTC

against

dupdog:

21-10-2011 01:54:21 UTC

against

Bucky:

21-10-2011 01:56:03 UTC

against on principle.

Additionally, it is plausible that Agora Nomic’s rules might declare several of their former-players (potentially including myself and the author of this CfJ) to be players again, in which case this CfJ backfires spectacularly.

Tavros:

21-10-2011 02:00:28 UTC

against

monqy:

21-10-2011 02:21:08 UTC

against

Ornithopter:

21-10-2011 02:27:02 UTC

for

redtara: they/them

21-10-2011 02:31:27 UTC

Bucky: see my patch.

pikhq:

21-10-2011 02:32:01 UTC

against

lazerchik:

21-10-2011 02:54:05 UTC

for

Brendan: he/him

21-10-2011 03:01:42 UTC

for

Amnistar: he/him

21-10-2011 03:24:20 UTC

for

Sgeo:

21-10-2011 03:27:25 UTC

against

Yally:

21-10-2011 03:50:54 UTC

against

omd:

21-10-2011 03:54:06 UTC

for

Roujo: he/him

21-10-2011 04:32:15 UTC

against

Tiger:

21-10-2011 09:56:54 UTC

against

Wooble:

21-10-2011 11:24:36 UTC

against

CWW:

21-10-2011 11:34:06 UTC

against

Prince Anduril:

21-10-2011 12:12:31 UTC

against

Rodney:

21-10-2011 13:46:49 UTC

against On the principle of being a patched CfJ.

lass:

21-10-2011 14:01:34 UTC

for

rebelyellow:

21-10-2011 14:04:09 UTC

for

lazerchik:

21-10-2011 14:24:57 UTC

for disregard previous vote, i was not active yet.

rebelyellow:

21-10-2011 14:32:51 UTC

for

ais523:

21-10-2011 16:36:52 UTC

against

Josh: Observer he/they

22-10-2011 10:32:56 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

22-10-2011 15:27:24 UTC

against