Friday, September 30, 2011

Proposal: Everyone’s a Critic

Timed out 8 votes to 3. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 03 Oct 2011 01:57:08 UTC

Create a new Rule, titled “Everyone’s a Critic”:

An Artist may post a Critique of another Artist’s non-Critique Work of Art.  In the Critique, he should delve into subtle details of the artwork, and speculate on the Artist’s hidden artistic goals, but eventually come to a close with a Positive or Negative evaluation. 

When three or more Artists have expressed Approval of the Critique, the critiqued Artist gains 1 Acclaim if the Critique was Positive, or loses 1 Acclaim if it was Negative.

What Artist wants to restrict their expression of Approval to a single arrow?

Comments

Bucky:

09-30-2011 21:10:02 UTC

imperial

bateleur:

09-30-2011 21:22:57 UTC

for Although it would be nice to see this rule modified later so that Critiques can have more relevance to them than just being maybe worth a point or two.

Klisz:

09-30-2011 22:19:10 UTC

for

Kevan:

09-30-2011 22:20:36 UTC

for Does seem like a lot of noise for a single point of Acclaim.

scshunt:

10-01-2011 01:19:45 UTC

against per Kevan

Josh:

10-01-2011 08:16:29 UTC

against

Blacky:

10-01-2011 08:47:46 UTC

for well yeah, but that can be amended

Darknight:

10-01-2011 14:38:16 UTC

for

ais523:

10-01-2011 16:05:22 UTC

for May just be a trivial bonus, but will add to the fun of the dynasty.

Prince Anduril:

10-02-2011 11:49:38 UTC

against